Your contribution scenario
This is a single contribution-year comparison, not an annual retirement plan. Verified rule years: 2025 and 2026. The 2025 option is a historical illustration; it does not reopen a contribution deadline.
Your comparison
Choose assumptions and select “Compare future wealth.” All values are nominal dollars. Investment returns and future tax rates are assumptions.
| Measure | Traditional strategy | Roth strategy |
|---|
View yearly after-tax liquidation values
Intermediate values are illustrations using the same future tax assumption and qualified-Roth treatment, not permission for an early withdrawal.
| Date | Traditional + side account | Roth + side account |
|---|
Why equal resources matter
A $5,000 Roth contribution and a $5,000 deductible traditional contribution have different current costs. With a 24% deduction benefit, investing all the savings can fund $5,000 ÷ (1 − 0.24) = $6,578.95 in the traditional account if limits permit. At a 24% future withdrawal rate, the two accounts then have equal after-tax value when their returns match.
For example, at 6% for 30 years, $5,000 in Roth becomes $28,717.46. The $6,578.95 traditional contribution becomes $37,786.13 before tax, or $28,717.46 after 24% tax. That equality changes when tax rates differ, caps bind, deductions are limited or tax savings are spent.
What the comparison includes
For each strategy, contributions minus current tax savings plus side-account deposits plus current spending equal your household budget. The invested strategy first uses tax savings to increase the traditional contribution, then places any cap surplus in the side account. The spent strategy shows tax savings as current consumption and leaves only unused contribution budget invested outside. Spending has value, but it is not added to future wealth.
Traditional IRA basis is contribution minus deduction. On full liquidation, only the value above that basis is taxed; investment losses never create a negative withdrawal tax. Nondeductible contributions generally require Form 8606. Existing aggregate IRA balances/basis are deliberately screened because their pro-rata treatment cannot be assigned to a single new account.
Qualified Roth values are tax-free. This model assumes ordinary owner accounts, full liquidation at ages 60–72, no future contributions, and tax benefits available at the contribution date. It excludes early-withdrawal exceptions, RMDs, backdoor conversions, inherited accounts, the Saver's Credit, tax-credit/benefit interactions and exact tax-return calculations. Check actual plan eligibility and tax treatment before contributing.
