Compare one full balance transfer to an otherwise empty card. Both paths use the same monthly payment budget. No new spending. Use actual offer terms and a budget that meets both issuers’ required minimum payments.
Your balance and offer
Your comparison
- Nominal advantage
- —
- Cash fee due today
- —
- New-card starting balance
- —
- Monthly amount to clear during promo
- —
| Measure | Keep old card | Transfer |
|---|
Monthly payments, interest and debt
| Month | New APR | Old payment | New payment | Old interest | New interest | Old debt | New debt | PV advantage |
|---|
How to compare a balance transfer
A lower introductory APR can reduce interest, but the transfer fee and later APR can offset that benefit. Compare the complete debt at the same date. This tool transfers the full entered balance, adds only the financed fee, and pays the cash portion today. If the full amount will not fit, it stops: it never discards a leftover old-card balance.
Monthly approximation and payment allocation
Each month’s interest equals opening balance × APR ÷ 1,200. Interest is added before a payment equal to the smaller of your budget and the amount due. Payment covers that month’s interest first and then principal; any unpaid interest stays in the balance. The whole transferred balance and financed fee form one rate bucket. The promo APR applies to months 1 through your entered promo period; the later APR starts the following month with no retroactive interest. That later APR remains fixed. The displayed monthly amount to clear the promo is rounded up to the next cent under this monthly model.
This is a monthly APR approximation, not a daily-average-balance or statement-accurate model. It excludes grace periods, exact transfer/statement dates, daily compounding, cent-by-cent lender rounding, rate changes, late/annual fees and penalties. Confirm the actual transfer fee, fee APR, credit capacity and minimum payment with the issuer. Different APR buckets, purchases, existing new-card debt, partial transfers and deferred-interest offers are unsupported. Deferred interest can charge earlier interest retroactively; an ordinary 0% introductory APR does not.
Equal resources and remaining debt
Both choices start with the same cash and old debt and receive the same monthly budget. Keeping the old card retains the cash fee that transferring would spend. After a final capped payment, unused budget is retained in either path. The table shows this cash accumulated at your net effective annual opportunity rate, with deposits at month end. Terminal position is retained cash minus remaining card debt.
The headline discounts actual card payments, any cash fee today and terminal debt by (1 + annual opportunity rate)month/12. Advantage is keep-card present cost minus transfer present cost. The terminal advantage is the same result grown to the comparison month, not an extra benefit added twice. Nominal advantage sets the opportunity rate to zero and equals old interest minus new interest minus the total fee. A lower payment alone never establishes savings. Payoff dates refer only to your selected comparison period.
A hand-checkable example
Transfer $1,000 with a $30 financed fee, 0% for two months and 12% afterward. Pay $400 per month under either option. The new balance is $630 after month 1 and $230 after month 2. Month 3 adds $2.30 interest and the final payment is $232.30. If the old card is at 12%, its balances are $610 and $216.10, then its final payment is $218.261. Old interest is $18.261; transfer interest plus fee is $32.30. Keeping is ahead by $14.039, or $14.04 rounded, despite the 0% promotion.
When the budget is too low
If a payment does not exceed monthly interest at a continuing fixed APR, debt does not shrink and this budget cannot pay it off. We flag nonamortization and retain the unpaid balance in the comparison. A balance remaining at the selected horizon does not necessarily mean it can never be paid off. Confirm both issuer minimums separately: this tool does not authorize paying less than required. Inputs support $0.01–$1 million of old debt, APRs of 0–50%, up to 120 promo months and 1–480 comparison months. A projected opening balance above $10 million stops the model. No approval, credit-score change, tax benefit or investment return is predicted.
