Enter the note rate and points from each quote. A point is 1% of the final note principal, including financed fees. Negative points mean a lender credit. This tool does not predict a rate reduction per point or lender approval. Defaults are illustrative, not current offers.
Your two quotes
Which quote costs less?
Enter two documented quotes, then compare.
- First-payment reduction with B
- —
- Nominal B advantage
- —
- Equivalent horizon advantage
- —
| Measure | Quote A | Quote B |
|---|---|---|
| Final note principal | — | — |
| Signed points charge / credit | — | — |
| Cash net fees at closing | — | — |
| Net fees financed | — | — |
| Monthly principal and interest | — | — |
| Payments through horizon | — | — |
| Interest through horizon | — | — |
| Remaining debt | — | — |
| Retained cash at horizon | — | — |
Monthly debt and cost advantage
| Month | A payment | B payment | A debt | B debt | B advantage today |
|---|
How points and financing are compared
Use actual written quotes for the same base proceeds and property. Rates and points are independent inputs. One point is 1% of the final note principal, not a promised reduction in the note rate. A negative entry is a credit against true closing fees, not cash back. Enter other economic fees separately, without counting the same point charge again.
If P is the common base loan, F is other true fees, and q is signed points divided by 100, a cash quote has note P and cash fees F + qP. When all net fees are financed, note N = (P + F) ÷ (1 − q), points = qN, and financed fees = N − P. For example, a $9,900 base loan with 1 point and no other fees has a $10,000 financed note and a $100 point charge. Computing just $99 would use the wrong basis. Verify financing availability and the actual rounded note/fee amounts with the lender. Partial fee financing and other point bases are outside this tool.
Monthly P&I is N × r ÷ [1 − (1+r)−n], with r = annual note percentage ÷ 1,200, or N ÷ n at zero. Both first payments occur in month 1. The model preserves unrounded payments and idealized fee amounts; lender cent rounding, daily interest and irregular first periods can change actual statements.
Both paths start with cash equal to the larger closing-cash requirement and receive the larger initial P&I amount each month. Each makes only its own contractual payments and retains the unused cash at the selected net return, including after payoff. A lower payment alone is not savings. Present cost = closing cash + discounted payments + discounted remaining debt. Quote B advantage = A cost − B cost. Retained cash minus debt gives the equivalent horizon advantage; it is the same benefit expressed later, not a second benefit to add.
Break-even is checked month by month
The first recovery month is the first observed month B is no worse by more than half a cent after previously being behind in today's dollars. This is a monthly comparison including debt, not points divided by payment savings. A credit can put B ahead at closing and then lose its advantage. The result identifies reversals and checks only the selected horizon. It does not promise that the first crossing lasts.
A hand-checkable quote
Borrow $12,000 for one month. A has a 12% annual note rate, no points or fees: one payment is $12,120. B has a 0% note rate and 0.5 points paid in cash: $60 at closing and a $12,000 payment. At a 0% opportunity rate, B starts $60 behind and is $60 ahead after month 1. Both debts are then zero. Charging 1 point instead would make the two total costs equal after month 1.
Scope and source
This compares fixed-rate, fully amortizing loans with cash or fully financed net true fees. Common down payment, taxes, insurance, escrow, prepaids and home value are assumed identical and cancel. Differing prepaids/escrow, PMI or guarantee insurance, temporary buydowns, variable rates, balloons, cash-out, extra principal, taxes/deductions and future refinancing are excluded. No eligibility or market-rate estimate is supplied. CFPB guidance, “How should I use lender credits and points (also called discount points)?”, checked November 3, 2026, explains percentage points/credits and why actual quoted rates must be compared. Ask your lender to identify the exact point basis and dollar amounts.
