Your result
Leasing costs less in present value
$353.71 over 36 months
Leasing costs $353.71 less in present value over 36 months at a 5.0% opportunity cost rate.
Out of date: fix the highlighted field to update.
- Buying, present cost
- $15,001
- At signing, over 36 months
- Leasing, present cost
- $14,648
- At signing, over 36 months
- Buying, nominal cost
- $15,172
- Over 36 months, undiscounted
- Leasing, nominal cost
- $15,700
- Over 36 months, undiscounted
- Purchase debt at end
- $10,469
- After 36 months
- Purchase loan payment
- $463.99
- Monthly, until payoff
Cash paid and value left at the endpoint
| Component | Buying | Leasing |
|---|---|---|
| Cash at signing | $6,000 | $2,000 |
| Later installments | $16,704 | $12,600 |
| Extra operating cash | $0 | $0 |
| Endpoint cash charge | $0 | $1,100 |
| Final debt | $10,469 | $0 |
| Less net owned value | −$18,000 | $0 |
| Nominal economic cost | $15,172 | $15,700 |
Show the math
- Buying reconciliation
- $22,703.54 cash + $10,468.88 debt − $18,000.00 net value = $15,172.42
- Leasing reconciliation
- $15,700.00 cash + $0.00 debt − $0.00 net value = $15,700.00
- Discounting
- Discount each monthly event by (1 + 5.0%) to the power month/12; final debt and value are at month 36. Loan interest uses 6.0% nominal annual / 12.
- Present-value difference
- $15,001.38 buying − $14,647.67 leasing = $353.71; positive favors leasing, negative favors buying.
Understanding car lease vs buy
What the result means
The headline compares the economic cost of two actual quotes over the same months and miles. Present value expresses those costs at signing using your opportunity cost rate. A lower lease payment alone does not establish a lower cost: buying can leave vehicle equity, while a lease return can add mileage and disposition charges. The nominal figures keep the same cash flows without discounting.
How it is calculated
Each option starts with cash actually paid, adds any debt still owed at the endpoint, and subtracts the net value of a vehicle you own. The purchased car's value is your estimate after selling costs for that same period and mileage. A lease returned to the lessor leaves no owned vehicle. A buyout leaves an asset and, if fully financed at that endpoint, a new debt. The reconciliation table shows these parts; the math panel discounts them at their actual monthly dates.
Other signing cash excludes installments. Choosing a first installment at signing counts one at month zero and one fewer later. Charges already capitalized in your quote are recorded for clarity and never added to cash again. The purchase loan uses monthly amortization at the fixed nominal annual note rate divided by twelve. Its payments stop at payoff, even when the vehicle is used longer.
Worked example
Suppose both quotes cover 36 months and 39,000 miles. Buying costs $30,000 all-in with $6,000 cash down, financing $24,000 for 60 months at a 6% nominal annual note rate. The monthly payment is about $463.99. After 36 payments, debt is about $10,469 and your estimated net vehicle value is $18,000. Cash paid plus debt less value gives about $15,172 nominal cost.
The tax-inclusive lease quote has $2,000 other signing cash and 36 installments of $350, starting in month one. Driving 3,000 miles above a 36,000-mile allowance at $0.25 a mile adds $750, with $350 other return charges. Its nominal cost is $15,700, so buying costs $527.58 less before discounting.
At an assumed 5% effective annual opportunity rate, buying has a present cost of about $15,001 and leasing about $14,648. Leasing costs $353.71 less in present value. The changed ranking comes from cash timing; no separate investment earnings are added.
What changes the result most
A higher net owned vehicle value lowers buying cost. A larger cash payment at signing changes timing, so the opportunity rate can change the ranking even when nominal totals stay close. Higher mileage may increase lease return charges and lower the purchased vehicle's market value; enter the corresponding value estimate yourself. Unequal insurance, fuel or maintenance costs can be entered separately as monthly amounts. Equal costs may be omitted from both options.
Limits and assumptions
This version supports term return, an actual early return settlement, and cash or fully financed buyout at the endpoint. An early quote includes all remaining obligations after the installments already modeled. A buyout quote includes its option price, remaining obligations, fees and taxes; return-only mileage, wear and disposition charges are not added after buyout. Check that the quote covers those obligations. There are no new buyout-loan payments or interest before an endpoint buyout.
The use period cannot extend past the quoted lease term. A longer comparison needs an explicit continuation arrangement; returning the car does not supply free later use. Refundable deposits, prepaid final installments, changing installments, lender-specific daily payoff calculations and unentered incentives or operating differences are outside this model.
Lease taxes depend on your contract and jurisdiction. Choose quote-inclusive amounts or explicitly add only omitted installment and cash taxes. Settlement and buyout endpoint quotes remain all-in. Purchase price already includes purchase taxes and fees. Outputs are pre-income-tax and exclude the federal vehicle-loan-interest deduction; that exclusion does not claim no such deduction exists. For a separate payment estimate, use the Auto Loan Calculator.
Frequently asked questions
Why can the nominal and present-value results disagree?
How do I count a first lease installment paid at signing?
Can I compare an early return or a buyout?
Can the comparison run longer than the lease?
Which taxes and other costs are included?
Sources
- CFPB — leasing versus buying, ownership, mileage and ending the lease (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
- Federal Reserve — vehicle leasing FAQ, quote charges and capitalized fees (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
- CFPB — simple-interest and precomputed auto loans (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
Explore related calculators

