Commodity Swaps: Cash Flow Examples
Table of Contents
Commodity swaps can help a business stabilize the benchmark component of recurring purchases or sales. An airline facing variable fuel bills and a producer facing variable selling prices need opposite sides of the same fixed-for-floating structure. To judge either hedge, combine its cash settlements with the physical transaction and then check what remains exposed.
What Are Commodity Swaps?
A commodity swap exchanges payments determined by commodity prices over agreed periods. This guide focuses on a cash-settled, fixed-for-floating price swap: one party pays an agreed fixed price times a reference quantity and receives an agreed floating index price times that quantity. The other party takes the opposite obligations. Payment netting can reduce the two amounts to one difference when the terms permit it.[1]
The swap in this guide supplies a price-related cash flow. It does not deliver the fuel, pay the supplier automatically or guarantee that the supplier’s price equals the swap index.
For a fuel consumer, pay fixed and receive floating offsets an increase in the referenced fuel price. For a producer, receive fixed and pay floating offsets a decline in the referenced selling price. These are two-way commitments: falling prices can require the consumer to pay, while rising prices can require the producer to pay.
Identifying the exact benchmark matters before comparing structures; the crude oil markets guide explains why market benchmarks and physical grades differ.
How Fixed-for-Floating Settlement Works
Define Qh as the month’s hedged quantity, K as the fixed price per unit and I as the contract’s floating price per unit. For the consumer paying fixed, define the signed settlement received as S:
If Qa is the actual purchased quantity and P is its invoice price per unit, the combined expense is:
The quantity and prices must use matching units and currency. Gallons multiplied by dollars per gallon produces dollars. This is a commodity-price calculation; the interest-accrual fraction used in an interest rate swap does not belong in this formula.
The Averaging Rule Is Part of the Contract
The floating price might be a single fixing or an average over a specified observation period. As a real specification example, AEGIS’s September 2023 Gulf Coast jet-fuel filing describes a monthly cash-settled swap in U.S. gallons. Its floating price averages specified daily Platts Gulf Coast Jet/Kero quotations across the relevant publication business days.[2] A month-end spot quote cannot substitute for that average.
Check the source, product grade, location, publication dates, averaging weights, corrections and missing-price provisions. The dates used to observe prices are separate from the date a resulting payment is due. A published product specification also does not establish the liquidity or availability of a trade for a particular business.
Monthly Commodity Swap Example
Suppose a fictional airline hedges 100,000 U.S. gallons per month for January, February and March 2027 at $2.50 per gallon. It pays fixed and receives floating. All prices, volumes and terms below are hypothetical; they are neither a forecast nor an actual airline’s hedge.
To make the arithmetic inspectable, this fictional contract uses exactly four equally weighted price observations each month. The dates are January 7, 14, 21 and 28; February 4, 11, 18 and 25; and March 4, 11, 18 and 25, 2027. Assume all observations are valid and published without correction. This four-date rule differs from the real AEGIS specification described above.
The airline initially purchases the full 100,000 gallons each month. Assume its physical invoice price equals the monthly swap index plus $0.10 per gallon, with no taxes or separate fees. Swap payments are due February 5, March 5 and April 5, 2027; the corresponding supplier invoices are due February 8, March 8 and April 8. These dates are invented terms, not market conventions. The reconciliation ignores financing costs, collateral and default.
| 2027 month | Four observations (USD/gallon) | Average I (USD/gallon) | Physical invoice (USD) | Swap received S (USD) | Net expense (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| January | 2.40, 2.50, 2.60, 2.70 | 2.55 | 265,000 | +5,000 received | 260,000 |
| February | 2.00, 2.10, 2.20, 2.30 | 2.15 | 225,000 | −35,000 paid | 260,000 |
| March | 2.60, 2.70, 2.80, 2.90 | 2.75 | 285,000 | +25,000 received | 260,000 |
| Three-month total | — | — | 775,000 | −5,000 net paid | 780,000 |
Each month ends at $2.60 per actual gallon, the $2.50 fixed benchmark component plus the assumed $0.10 differential. The airline achieves that result even though its swap loses money overall: $775,000 of supplier invoices plus $5,000 net paid on the swap equals $780,000 for 300,000 gallons.
January: I = ($2.40 + $2.50 + $2.60 + $2.70) / 4 = $2.55. The swap pays the airline 100,000 × ($2.55 − $2.50) = $5,000. The physical invoice is 100,000 × ($2.55 + $0.10) = $265,000, leaving $265,000 − $5,000 = $260,000.
February: I = ($2.00 + $2.10 + $2.20 + $2.30) / 4 = $2.15. S = 100,000 × ($2.15 − $2.50) = −$35,000. The lower $225,000 supplier invoice plus the $35,000 swap payment again equals $260,000.
March: I = ($2.60 + $2.70 + $2.80 + $2.90) / 4 = $2.75. The $25,000 swap receipt offsets part of the $285,000 invoice: $285,000 − $25,000 = $260,000.
The Producer Takes the Other Direction
For a separate hypothetical producer selling 100,000 gallons, use February’s $2.15 index and $2.50 fixed price, but assume the physical selling price is the index minus $0.08. Physical revenue is 100,000 × $2.07 = $207,000. A receive-fixed/pay-floating swap adds 100,000 × ($2.50 − $2.15) = $35,000, giving $242,000, or $2.42 per gallon.
The producer fixes the benchmark component while retaining its selling differential. If the index rises above the fixed price, the producer owes money on the swap. Calling that structure a revenue floor without explaining the required payments would confuse it with one-way option protection.
What Basis and Volume Risks Remain?
For this analysis, define the basis differential b = P − I: the actual invoice price minus the swap index. It can reflect grade, delivery location, freight, taxes, timing and purchasing weights. An airline buying more fuel on expensive days can have a different average purchase price from an index that gives every observation equal weight.
When Qa = Qh = Q and P = I + b, the index cancels algebraically:
A Wider Basis Raises the Net Cost
Change only March’s physical differential from $0.10 to $0.25 per gallon. The physical price becomes $2.75 + $0.25 = $3.00, so the invoice rises to $300,000. The swap still receives $25,000. Net expense becomes $275,000, or $2.75 per gallon: $15,000 above the original case. That difference is 100,000 × ($0.25 − $0.10).
A swap referencing a related commodity rather than the purchased product adds another potential mismatch. The separate cross hedging guide covers statistical hedge sizing; a convenient contract name does not establish a reliable offset.
A Quantity Shortfall Creates an Overhedge
Reset to February’s original $2.15 index and $0.10 differential. Suppose canceled flights reduce actual purchases to 60,000 gallons, while the swap still covers 100,000. The airline pays 60,000 × $2.25 = $135,000 for fuel and still owes $35,000 on the swap. Total expense is $170,000, or about $2.83 per actual gallon.
A quantity-matched 60,000-gallon hedge would have produced 60,000 × $2.60 = $156,000 of combined expense. The $14,000 difference equals the 40,000 excess hedged gallons × the $0.35 fixed-minus-floating price difference. Those excess gallons have no physical purchase to offset their swap payment. Higher-than-forecast purchases instead leave some fuel unhedged.
Commodity Swaps vs. Futures Strips
A futures strip holds positions across consecutive contract months.[3] To compare it with the airline’s swap, start with the same January–March exposure and 100,000 gallons per month. Then check whether the available contracts reference the same commodity, unit and monthly averaging rule. A future settling to one day’s price is not the same payoff as a swap averaging four dates.
| Feature | Fixed-for-floating swap | Futures strip |
|---|---|---|
| Matching the exposure | Agreed quantity, reference and dates may fit the business; supported terms and dealer availability constrain the choice. | Listed sizes, months and settlement specifications constrain the fit; quantity rounding can remain. |
| Cash timing | Scheduled commodity payments; interim collateral or margin may also be required. | Daily gains and losses are settled through the margin system, before the eventual physical invoice. |
| Trading and exit | Check available quotes and documented termination or transfer terms, including consent and costs. | Check actual depth and spreads for each month; a distant or specialized contract may be difficult to offset. |
| Credit arrangements | May be bilateral or centrally cleared, depending on the product and arrangement. | Centrally cleared, with clearing-member and clearinghouse arrangements to examine. |
CME explains that futures gains and losses are settled daily and additional resources may be required after losses.[4] Its 2022 commodity-index article also describes centrally cleared S&P GSCI and Bloomberg Commodity Index swaps.[5] Commodity swaps therefore should not all be labeled uncleared or unmargined; that example does not establish a clearing route for our fictional jet-fuel trade.
See commodity futures for contract selection and carrying-cost concepts. A single forward contract can address one future transaction; a recurring swap schedule addresses several periods. The label alone does not determine the best match or the total funding needed.
Collateral Can Be Due Before Hedge Benefits Arrive
A monthly commodity payment and an interim collateral call answer different questions. The first uses the realized contractual index for that period. The second depends on the applicable credit-support terms and a valuation of outstanding obligations. CFTC’s uncleared-margin definitions tie variation margin to changes in value; its framework has specified scope and exceptions.[6]
For illustration, suppose the airline’s actual bilateral agreement requires $20,000 cash collateral on February 11, due February 12, 2027, based on an interim valuation. This is an additional invented assumption, not a value calculated from the completed February average. The lower February fuel invoice is not due until March 8, so its eventual saving does not provide cash for the earlier call.
The collateral transfer is not automatically an additional permanent $20,000 hedge loss. Its later return, credit or application to settlement depends on the agreement. Reconcile that treatment so the same cash is not counted twice. Budget separately for any initial margin, upfront payment, dealer spread, fees, collateral funding and early termination amount; a fixed price quotation does not prove that no cash is needed at inception or afterward.
How to Evaluate a Commodity Swap
- Map the physical exposure by month. Record expected purchases or sales, units, pricing terms, payment dates and plausible volume shortfalls.
- Read the floating-price definition. Compare source, grade, location, observation calendar and weighting with the actual invoice formula.
- Confirm direction and signed payments. Calculate both high-price and low-price scenarios, then combine the swap with the physical cash flow.
- Stress basis and quantity separately. Change the differential, reduce actual volume and check uncovered or excess quantities.
- Build a dated funding schedule. Include invoices, commodity settlements, collateral calls, available cash and committed funding resources.
- Check the full arrangement. Review counterparties or clearing arrangements, valuation and dispute terms, default and termination provisions, transfer requirements and all costs.
These documentation questions have practical substance: the CFTC relationship-documentation rule addresses payments, valuation, termination, transfer and credit support for its covered relationships, subject to its applicability conditions.[7] The checklist does not substitute for reviewing a business’s actual documents or arranging professional legal and accounting advice.
Common Mistakes
- Scoring the swap alone. A swap payment can accompany a lower physical invoice. Evaluate the combined result against the stated hedging objective.
- Using a month-end quote for an average-price swap. Rebuild the specified observation series and weighting.
- Dropping negative settlements. The fixed-price consumer must pay when the floating index is below the fixed price.
- Calling the full delivered price fixed. The local differential, taxes or other charges can remain variable.
- Leaving an outdated quantity in place. Reduced consumption or production can turn part of the hedge into an unmatched price position.
- Equating monthly settlement with monthly-only funding. Read collateral terms and stress the timing of cash calls.
Limitations and Access
The hypothetical calculations describe economic offsets under specified assumptions. They do not value a proposed trade, demonstrate hedge-accounting qualification or establish its tax treatment. Nor does the swap ensure that a supplier delivers fuel or that a producer can make the planned sales.
U.S. OTC swaps should not be presented as an ordinary retail product. Commodity Exchange Act section 2(e) restricts swap participation by persons who are not eligible contract participants, with an exception for swaps entered into on or subject to the rules of a designated contract market.[8] Actual eligibility, clearing, reporting and margin obligations depend on the parties and transaction; describing a commercial hedge does not decide those questions.
A promised receipt helps the physical exposure only if it is paid when required. Collateral and central clearing can change and reduce credit exposure, but they do not make every arrangement risk-free. Read the separate counterparty credit risk guide for exposure and mitigation concepts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
- Bloomberg SEF: amended rulebook filing, November 30, 2016. Historical Rules 1564–1565, Gulf Coast jet-fuel fixed/floating and strip contracts; PDF pages 280–281 using one-based numbering.
- AEGIS SEF: Chapter 1402, Gulf Coast Jet Fuel Fixed Swap specification. Monthly averaging, gallons and cash settlement; CFTC filing record dated September 18, 2023.
- CME Group: Glossary. Strip and Swap (OTC) entries; educational definitions remain subject to actual contract rules.
- CME Group: Mark-to-Market. Daily futures settlement and margin funding.
- CME Group: Cleared OTC Swaps on Commodity Indexes, 2022. Examples of supported cleared commodity-index swaps.
- CFTC: 17 CFR 23.150, Scope, and 17 CFR 23.151, margin definitions. Scoped uncleared-margin framework and variation-margin definition.
- CFTC: 17 CFR 23.504, Swap trading relationship documentation. Applicability and paragraphs (b)(1)–(4).
- Commodity Exchange Act: 7 U.S.C. § 2(e). Participation restriction and designated-contract-market exception.
Sources accessed November 15, 2026. The eCFR displayed Title 17 current through November 12, 2026; the U.S. Code page displayed laws in effect through November 10, 2026. Filed specifications illustrate their dated terms and are not current trading recommendations.
Disclaimer
This article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, legal, tax or accounting advice. All worked prices, quantities and payment dates are hypothetical. Derivative obligations, access, collateral and hedge treatment depend on the actual transaction and applicable rules. Consult qualified professionals before entering a hedge.
