Churning and Unauthorized Trading: How to Review Brokerage Activity

Table of Contents

    If a trade appears in your U.S. brokerage account that you did not approve, call the brokerage firm immediately and follow up in writing. Use the number on your statement or the firm’s official website. Save the trade confirmation and your order records. You can raise a specific discrepancy before you know why it happened or whether other trades are involved. [1] [2]

    Churning and unauthorized trading can overlap, but they raise different questions. For one trade, ask who had authority and what order they gave. For a series of trades, ask who recommended them, what the series cost and whether it fit the account’s objectives. The steps below help you document both and decide where to raise each concern.

    What to Do When You Spot an Unfamiliar Trade

    1. Contact the firm and identify the trade. Give the trade date, security, side, quantity and order or confirmation reference. Tell the firm what you recognize and what you dispute. Ask for its explanation, how it recorded the order and what can be done about any related pending orders. If you see signs of account takeover, such as a contact change you didn’t make, ask for the fraud or security team and follow its instructions to protect access. [1] [13]
    2. Send a dated written dispute. Use the firm’s official complaint channel or secure message system and direct it to the branch manager or compliance department if you do not get a satisfactory response. State which trade or portion you dispute, what you asked for, and what response or correction you want. If the statement names a separate clearing firm, FINRA advises reporting statement discrepancies in writing to both firms. Keep your message, its delivery record, any case number and the firm’s response. [1] [2]
    3. Preserve the original records. Save confirmations, account statements, order history, relevant secure messages or emails, and your account agreement and trading authorizations. Record the date you first noticed the trade and keep a log of calls and responses. Ask the firm to preserve relevant order records, communications and recordings if any exist. Send copies through official channels and keep the originals. [2] [11]

    If the concern continues, see where to report it or seek recovery. Do not wait for a full account review to contest an unfamiliar trade or get advice on a potential filing deadline. [1] [12]

    Unauthorized Trading, Excessive Trading and Churning

    Permission, trading frequency and fill quality are separate questions

    Unauthorized trading concerns whether there was permission for the transaction. Excessive trading concerns whether a broker’s trading or series of recommendations was excessive in light of the applicable standard and the customer’s circumstances. Churning, in the traditional federal antifraud sense, adds actual or effective control of the account and intent to defraud or reckless disregard of the customer’s interests. Generating commissions can be a motive, but fees alone do not establish fraud. [5] [6] [8]

    Which question does the account activity raise?
    What you see What to check first
    One unrecognized trade Find the instruction or written authority in effect that day. Check the security, side and quantity. A single trade is enough to raise an authorization concern.
    Repeated buys and sells suggested by the broker Compare the whole series, its costs and the documented account profile. Approving each trade does not settle whether the recommendations were excessive as a group.
    Many trades you decided on independently Measure the cost of the activity if useful. High turnover alone does not establish that someone recommended or controlled the trades.
    An authorized order fills at a worse price than expected Compare your instruction, market conditions and the fill. See trading execution and slippage for that separate question.

    Actual or effective control matters to the traditional antifraud churning analysis. Current recommendation rules ask a different question. Under Regulation Best Interest (Reg BI), a broker-dealer making covered securities recommendations to a retail customer must have a reasonable basis to believe the series, taken together, is not excessive and is in that customer’s best interest, without putting the broker’s interests first. That requirement does not depend on the broker controlling the account. FINRA Rule 2111 excludes recommendations covered by Reg BI. Where Rule 2111 still applies, its current quantitative suitability provision evaluates the series against the customer’s profile; FINRA removed its former account-control requirement effective June 30, 2020. [5] [6] [7] [10]

    Who Had Authority to Place the Trade?

    Start with the instruction for that order. In a nondiscretionary brokerage account, a recommendation to buy does not itself give the broker permission to execute it. For discretionary brokerage trades, FINRA Rule 3260 generally requires prior written customer authorization to one or more named individuals and written acceptance by the firm. The firm must promptly approve discretionary orders in writing and review discretionary accounts at frequent intervals. Check the authority’s effective dates, restrictions and the person covered. An unrecognized trade can be within a valid mandate, and a discretionary mandate does not excuse excessive trading. [3] [4]

    A narrow exception lets a broker choose the execution time or price for an order you gave for a definite amount of a specified security. For an ordinary retail order, that discretion generally ends that business day unless you give a specific contrary instruction in signed, dated writing. It does not let the broker choose a different security or change how many shares you authorized. A related distinction: advisory describes the service relationship; discretionary describes who can decide to trade. The firm may offer both brokerage and advisory services. Check your agreement and Form CRS, the firm’s relationship summary, for the capacity in which the professional was acting. For ownership and third-party permissions, see the individual brokerage account guide. [3] [4]

    Reconcile the Confirmation With the Order and Statement

    For each disputed order, compare your instructions or order history with the confirmation and the statement activity. Record the trade and settlement dates, security, side, quantity, price, fees, and who initiated or recommended it. A single order can have several fills. Match the order reference and total quantity, and distinguish a trade from a transfer, dividend reinvestment or correction. If a broker’s recommendation shows up as unsolicited on a confirmation, keep the communication that shows whose idea it was and ask the firm about the discrepancy. A label is evidence to check, not proof of what happened. [2] [8]

    Worked example: The statement balances, but the share count is disputed

    Suppose your record shows an order to buy 50 shares, but the confirmation shows a purchase of 100 shares at $40 with a $5 commission. The total debit was 100 × $40 + $5 = $4,005. The statement shows that the 20 shares you already held increased to 120: 20 + 100 = 120.

    For the same statement period, cash reconciles too: $8,000 opening cash + $1,500 deposit − $4,005 purchase debit + $60 cash dividend − $15 unrelated account fee = $5,540 ending cash. When doing this yourself, match like balances: do not compare unsettled trade activity with a settled-only cash total without accounting for the timing.

    The statement and confirmation agree about what posted. Your dispute is the 50-share difference between your instruction and the reported fill. Tell the firm you recognize the first 50 shares and dispute the additional 50, and ask what instruction or authority it relied on. The cash debit shows the purchase amount and commission; it is not a measure of your loss.

    Measure a Pattern: Turnover and Cost-to-Equity

    Turnover estimates how much was bought compared with the capital in the account. Cost-to-equity estimates how much the account would need to earn on its average equity just to cover the trading costs you counted. Pick one period and use that same period for purchases, costs and balances. The SEC has used total purchases and average account equity, including a case that averaged month-end values. The simple version below assumes complete monthly balances and no large inflows or outflows. [7] [8]

    Turnover for the period
    Turnover = Total purchase value ÷ Average net account equity
    Express the result in times. Count the value of purchases before separate fees; do not add sale proceeds or treat deposits and transfers as purchases.
    Cost-to-equity for the same period
    Cost-to-equity (%) = (Identified trading costs ÷ Average net account equity) × 100
    Use documented commissions, other identifiable trading charges and trading-related margin interest. If a markup or markdown is embedded in price, document it if you can verify it, and count it only once. Keep unrelated account fees and estimated spread or slippage separate from this recorded-cost calculation.
    Worked example: Three months of purchases and costs

    Suppose there are no deposits or withdrawals in a quarter. Use month-end equity net of any margin debt, and assume the charges below are the trading costs you can verify.

    Hypothetical three-month account review in U.S. dollars
    Input Arithmetic Result
    Average net equity ($48,000 + $50,000 + $52,000) ÷ 3 $50,000
    Total purchases $65,000 + $70,000 + $60,000 $195,000
    Documented trading costs $1,200 commissions + $180 other trading charges + $420 margin interest $1,800
    Quarterly turnover $195,000 ÷ $50,000 3.90 times
    Quarterly cost-to-equity ($1,800 ÷ $50,000) × 100 3.60%

    That is 3.90 times average equity in purchases and a 3.60% burden from the measured costs over the quarter. To express a simple annual pace, multiply both by four: 15.60 times and 14.40%. Label those as annualized estimates, not observed annual results or forecasts. If the quarter includes a one-off strategy change, multiplying by four can overstate how often it happens.

    Interpret the Numbers in Context

    Look for short holding periods, repeated exits and re-entries, and a sustained cost burden that does not fit the documented objective. Compare risk tolerance, time horizon and liquidity needs with what the broker actually recommended. Ask for the rationale for the series, an itemization of trading costs and the return needed to cover them. An account that gained money can still merit review. No single turnover rate or cost-to-equity ratio proves excessive trading or clears the account. [7] [8]

    • Historical suitability example: In its October 21, 2026 Colletti opinion, the SEC reported 10.31 times turnover and 72.14% cost-to-equity for May 2018 through February 2019. Those figures cover ten months. The Commission assessed them alongside unauthorized trades, frequent in-and-out activity and the investor’s moderate risk tolerance near retirement. The findings concerned unauthorized and excessive trading under the rules for that earlier conduct. [8]
    • Reg BI example: In a 2023 settled order, the SEC found that Laidlaw’s representatives recommended a costly series of in-and-out trades to six retail customers from July 2020 through October 2021. Several customers had reported high risk tolerance or speculative objectives. Those preferences did not relieve the broker of the obligation to assess whether the series served their interests. The firm settled without admitting or denying the findings, apart from the order’s jurisdiction provisions. [9]

    Where to Report the Problem or Seek Recovery

    Three routes serving different purposes
    Route Purpose and next step
    Written brokerage complaint Notify the firm, ask for its investigation and request the correction or response you want. Keep a copy and record the date. [1]
    Regulatory complaint or tip Use FINRA’s investor complaint page for a broker or brokerage firm. The SEC has an investor complaint route and a separate route for suspected securities fraud. Provide a factual timeline and relevant copies. Reporting can lead to a regulatory response; it does not file a private claim or guarantee payment. [1] [11]
    Arbitration or other private dispute resolution If you seek compensation or other relief, check your agreement and the forum rules promptly. Many brokerage agreements specify arbitration. FINRA Rule 12200 also addresses covered disputes brought to FINRA at the customer’s request. Mediation is voluntary and aims at a settlement; arbitrators can issue a binding decision. [12]

    To start a FINRA arbitration when it is the appropriate forum, see FINRA’s filing instructions. The usual filing includes a Statement of Claim with the facts and requested relief, a signed and dated Submission Agreement, and the required filing fee. The Dispute Resolution Portal is the usual route. Under Rule 12300(a)(2), self-represented customers may file outside the portal, but if they file their claim through it, they must keep using it throughout the arbitration. Keep the filing receipt. The SEC did not intend Reg BI to create a new private right to sue; which claims or remedies are available depends on your facts and applicable law. [6] [12]

    A complaint does not start arbitration

    FINRA Rule 12206 generally makes a claim ineligible for arbitration once six years have elapsed from the occurrence or event giving rise to it. The panel decides eligibility, and separate statutes of limitations can be shorter. Do not assume FINRA’s six-year period starts when you noticed the problem, or that complaining to the firm or a regulator pauses a deadline. A securities attorney can help assess the relevant event, deadline and forum. Seek that advice promptly if you may want to recover losses. [12]

    Common Mistakes and Limits of a Statement Review

    • Waiting to finish the spreadsheet. Report an unfamiliar trade immediately. For ongoing monitoring after that, a transaction ledger can help you reconcile purchases and fees against the originals. [1] [2]
    • Mixing periods or counting a cost twice. A commission on a confirmation may appear again on the statement. Reconcile it once; label costs you could not verify, rather than treating them as zero. [2] [8]
    • Relying on a distorted denominator. A substantial deposit or withdrawal within the month can make a month-end average unrepresentative, and very small or nonpositive equity can make the ratios misleading or unusable. Keep the underlying balances and cash flows, state how you measured equity and ask how the firm calculated any ratio it gives you.
    • Treating the ledger as a verdict. A confirmation records the execution, and the ratios describe activity and costs. They cannot establish consent, motive, causation or recoverable damages. Preserve the instructions, recommendations and account profile that give the numbers meaning. [5] [8]

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Yes. Compare the order or applicable trading authority with the confirmation. Call and write to the firm about the discrepancy promptly; you do not need to find a pattern first. [1] [3]

    Yes. Approval bears on permission. The separate Reg BI question for covered recommendations is whether the recommended series, as a whole, was excessive or failed to serve your best interest. [6]

    No. Look for other transaction charges, embedded markups or markdowns where applicable, and trading-related margin interest. The spread or slippage may also affect results; record any such estimates separately from documented charges. [2] [8] [10]

    Filing a regulatory complaint does not request an arbitration award or assure recovery. Review the firm response and your separate dispute options promptly, including the deadline that applies to any claim. [1] [12]

    Save the statements, original confirmations, order history, communications about the trades, fee records, account profile and any authorizations in effect. Keep the written complaint and the firm’s response. A ledger is useful as an index to those records. [2] [8]

    Sources

    1. FINRA, File a Complaint.
    2. FINRA, Understanding Brokerage Account Statements and Trade Confirmations; Are You Checking Your Trade Confirmations?
    3. FINRA Rule 3260, Discretionary Accounts.
    4. SEC, How to Open a Brokerage Account; Investor.gov, Form CRS; SEC, Opening an Investment Advisory Account.
    5. SEC, Simpson and Pattee opinion, May 14, 2002; FINRA, 3 Ways to Guard Against Excessive Trading.
    6. 17 CFR § 240.15l-1, Regulation Best Interest; SEC adopting release, July 12, 2019.
    7. FINRA Rule 2111, Suitability; Regulatory Notice 20-18, June 19, 2020.
    8. SEC, Colletti opinion, October 21, 2026, pp. 5–6; Excessive Trading at Investors’ Expense; Reg BI FAQ.
    9. SEC, Laidlaw settled order, November 20, 2023, part III.
    10. FINRA Rule 5310, Best Execution and Interpositioning; Regulatory Notice 18-29.
    11. SEC, Investor Complaints, updated September 8, 2026.
    12. FINRA Customer Arbitration Code: Rule 12200, When arbitration is required; Rule 12206, Time limits; Rule 12300, Filing and serving documents; Rule 12302, Initial statement of claim. Also see SEC, Broker-Dealer/Customer Arbitration.
    13. FINRA, Customer Account Takeovers.

    This article provides general education about U.S. brokerage accounts and is not individualized legal or investment advice. The worked account examples are hypothetical. Rules and reporting routes were checked November 17, 2026. Consult a qualified securities attorney about your claim, available remedies and filing deadlines.