WorldCom Accounting Fraud: Line Costs
Table of Contents
WorldCom paid other carriers to transmit calls and data, then moved billions of dollars of those operating costs into asset accounts. The bills did not go away. The accounting made the U.S. telecom company look more profitable and, when the payments were shown as investments, made operations appear to generate more cash. For an investor, the case shows how the same accounting decision can make both earnings and operating cash flow look stronger than they were. [1] [2]
What Was the WorldCom Accounting Fraud?
Line costs included fees WorldCom owed other telecom carriers for carrying part of a voice call or a data transmission. WorldCom’s policy was to expense access costs as incurred, including estimated costs for service it had received but had yet to be billed for. Buying equipment for its own network was a different transaction: qualifying costs could go on the balance sheet as an asset and be expensed over time through depreciation. [1] [2]
A bill for carrying this month’s calls is an operating expense. A purchase of equipment the carrier will use for years can be a capital expenditure. Paying for unused capacity or expecting more demand later did not turn WorldCom’s ordinary line costs into a network asset.
WorldCom’s investigative committee found that the company first reduced reported line costs through improper reversals of accrued expenses in 1999 and 2000. As large accruals available for release ran down, improper capitalization became the main tactic from the first quarter of 2001 through the first quarter of 2002. Both tactics made line costs look lower in the income statement, but one improperly reduced liabilities while the other inflated assets. [1]
How WorldCom Moved Line Costs Into Assets
Suppose a carrier has received network service and will pay the bill later. These are the ordinary entries and the improper entry WorldCom’s case illustrates. A debit to expense records the cost; a credit to that same expense account reverses it.
| Event | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Recognize the cost when service is received | Line-cost expense | Accrued payable |
| Settle the bill | Accrued payable | Cash |
| Improper transfer after recognizing the cost | Construction in progress | Line-cost expense |
If the carrier pays immediately, it can debit expense and credit cash directly. Either way, the third row is a separate misstatement. It never pays the supplier a second time or changes the obligation. The committee documented a $560 million transfer to construction in progress for the second quarter of 2001. It also found a separate $50 million transfer from line costs to selling, general and administrative expense. That second entry reduced reported line costs without reducing total expenses or raising pre-tax income. [1]
Worked Example: The Same Payment Across Three Statements
An illustrative carrier starts with $50 million in cash, $100 million in net property, plant and equipment (PP&E), $150 million in equity, and no liabilities. In one period it collects $300 million of revenue and pays $140 million in other operating costs, $60 million for carrier service already received, and $40 million for equipment bought late in the period. It records $20 million of depreciation on existing equipment and none on the new equipment, which is not yet in service. Assume no interest, taxes, working capital changes, financing, or distributions.
EBITDA is earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization. Cash from operating activities (CFO) measures cash flows classified as operating on the statement of cash flows. Cash paid for ordinary supplier services belongs in operating activities; cash paid to acquire productive equipment belongs in investing activities. Here, the misstated version moves the $60 million expense into construction in progress with no current depreciation, and shows the payment as investing. [3] [4]
| Measure | Correct | Misstated |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA | 300 − 140 − 60 = 100 | 300 − 140 = 160 |
| Net income | 100 − 20 = 80 | 160 − 20 = 140 |
| CFO | 80 + 20 = 100 | 140 + 20 = 160 |
| Cash capex (amount spent) | 40 | 40 + 60 = 100 |
| Net investing cash flow | −40 | −100 |
| Free cash flow (CFO less cash capex) | 100 − 40 = 60 | 160 − 100 = 60 |
| Closing cash | 50 + 100 − 40 = 110 | 50 + 160 − 100 = 110 |
| Closing net PP&E, including construction in progress | 100 + 40 − 20 = 120 | 100 + 40 + 60 − 20 = 180 |
| Closing assets and equity (no liabilities) | 110 + 120 = 150 + 80 = 230 | 110 + 180 = 150 + 140 = 290 |
The $60 million lifts reported earnings and assets, but the same dollars leave the bank account. Showing the payment in investing raises both CFO and reported cash capital expenditures (capex) by $60 million, so the increases cancel in the free cash flow (FCF) calculation shown here. That is one common definition of FCF; companies and analysts can use others. If the service was unpaid at period end, there would be no cash payment to move between categories in that period. [4]
Notice that EBITDA and CFO happen to equal each other in this example because of the assumptions. They answer different questions. Later depreciation on a false asset could reduce future net income and the carrying value without another cash payment. It would not put the original service bill back into EBITDA, which excludes depreciation.
Legitimate Capitalization vs. WorldCom’s Treatment
Purchasing productive equipment
- A carrier acquires a qualifying asset, records it in PP&E and depreciates it over its useful life once it is in service.
- The cash purchase is an investing outflow and the asset record can be traced to equipment received.
Relabeling an operating cost
- A carrier records an asset for services it has already consumed, understating current expenses.
- Showing the paid bill as investing overstates cash from operations without improving cash generation.
A genuine advance payment for a future service can establish a prepaid asset. That does not make money paid for this period’s service a capital investment. The key question is what right or resource remains at the reporting date. [1] [2] [3]
Discovery, Disclosure and Restatement
WorldCom’s internal audit team, led by Cynthia Cooper, traced capital-account entries that lacked support and brought the issue to the audit committee. On June 24, 2002, former auditor Arthur Andersen told WorldCom that its FY 2001 audit report and Q1 2002 review could no longer be relied on. The company disclosed the transfers the following day. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filed suit on June 26, and WorldCom filed for Chapter 11 reorganization on July 21. [1] [2] [5] [6]
| Record | Amount | What it measures |
|---|---|---|
| June 25, 2002 company disclosure [5] | $3.852 billion | Initial improper transfers: $3.055 billion in FY 2001 plus $797 million in Q1 2002. |
| June 26, 2002 SEC complaint [6] | $3.055 billion and $797 million, respectively | The SEC alleged overstatements of earnings before taxes and minority interests in those two periods. These were allegations at filing. |
| March 31, 2003 investigative committee report [1] | $3.506 billion capitalized; $3.883 billion in combined line-cost adjustments | The report’s five-quarter table adds $377 million of other adjustments to its capitalization subtotal. |
| July 7, 2003 district court opinion [7] | Estimated $11 billion | Broader overstatement of income across multiple years. It is neither the capitalization total nor a cash loss. |
To see what the original complaint meant, subtract the alleged FY 2001 overstatement of $3.055 billion from the reported result of $2.393 billion before taxes and minority interests. The result is a loss of about $662 million on that same basis. That was the complaint’s estimate, not the final restated net loss. [6]
In its FY 2002 Form 10-K, filed in March 2004, WorldCom restated the comparative annual statements for 2000 and 2001. Note 4 identifies $2.8 billion of improperly capitalized FY 2001 access costs that were reversed, among other corrections. That figure covers one annual period. Do not add the amounts in the table or use their differences to infer how much cash moved. [2]
What WorldCom’s Cash-Flow Filings Show
The worked example isolates one entry and one misclassified payment. WorldCom’s actual restatement corrected more than that, including which businesses were reflected in its consolidated statements. Compare the same fiscal year across the two filings. Here, cash capex is the positive amount of capital expenditures (original filing) or PP&E additions (restated filing). [8] [2]
| Measure | Original FY 2001 filing | FY 2001 in restated filing |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 35,179 | 37,668 |
| CFO | 7,994 | 2,845 |
| Cash capex | 7,886 | 6,465 |
| Derived FCF | 7,994 − 7,886 = 108 | 2,845 − 6,465 = −3,620 |
| Derived cash capex as a share of revenue | 7,886 / 35,179 ≈ 22.4% | 6,465 / 37,668 ≈ 17.2% |
The restated CFO was $5,149 million lower, while cash capex was $1,421 million lower. Under the same definition, derived FCF decreased by $5,149 million minus $1,421 million, or $3,728 million. WorldCom attributed the 2001 CFO change primarily to correcting improperly capitalized access and other costs. The before-and-after comparison also reflects other corrections, so it cannot isolate the FCF effect of the line-cost transfers. [2]
How to Spot Similar Warning Signs in Filings
- Compare margins with the cost of delivering service. Track line costs as a percentage of revenue if disclosed. The committee reconstructed WorldCom’s Q1 2001 ratio at about 50%, versus 42% reported. When profit margins hold up despite pricing pressure or rising input costs, look for a business explanation such as better supplier terms or a shift in what the company sells. [1]
- Check what increased capex actually bought. Compare cash capex relative to revenue over time, then look at asset additions, construction in progress, and management’s description of projects. The committee compared WorldCom’s published Q1 2001 capex of $2,235 million with $1,691 million actually spent, a gap of $544 million. The committee had records a public investor would not normally see. [1]
- Read operating and investing cash flow together. Ask how much of the CFO change is explained by collections, supplier payments, or working capital. Check the cash capex line separately; total investing cash flow can include acquisitions, asset sales and other transactions. Use consistent definitions and consolidation scope when comparing periods or peers. [3]
Civil and Criminal Outcomes and the Sarbanes-Oxley Act
The U.S. district court entered a permanent injunction against WorldCom on November 26, 2002. Its July 7, 2003 consent judgment imposed a $2.25 billion civil penalty, with terms allowing WorldCom to satisfy the judgment upon reorganization with $500 million in cash and $250 million in reorganized company stock. The company consented without admitting or denying the SEC’s second amended allegations except as to jurisdiction. In a separate criminal case, a jury convicted former CEO Bernard Ebbers in March 2005, and the Second Circuit affirmed his conviction and 25-year sentence in July 2006. [9] [10]
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act became U.S. law on July 30, 2002, in the broader reporting crisis that included WorldCom and the Enron scandal. The House bill that became the vehicle for the law had been introduced in February, before WorldCom’s disclosure. As enacted, Section 101 established the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, Section 302 directed officer certification rules for periodic reports, and Section 404 addressed management’s assessment of internal control over financial reporting and auditor attestation. These are historical provisions, not a list of current requirements for every issuer. [11] [12]
Common Mistakes
- Treating EBITDA as cash in the bank. It excludes depreciation and amortization and does not show when customers paid, suppliers were paid, or cash went to investing activities.
- Assuming higher CFO always improves FCF. An equal rise in reported cash capex offsets the rise under CFO minus cash capex. Check the definition and the underlying transactions.
- Calling the whole $11 billion capitalized expense. The court’s figure was a broad income estimate. Start by identifying the source, time period and account affected.
Limits of the Case Study
A real network buildout can raise the capex ratio and an efficient carrier can reduce its operating costs. Public filings can help you identify changes to investigate, but they rarely show the journal entries or invoices needed to prove a specific accounting misstatement.
Frequently Asked Questions
It took charges for services already received out of current expenses and recorded them as assets. Removing expenses raised current earnings without lowering what WorldCom owed its suppliers.
Yes. If classifying the same payment as capital spending raises reported CFO and reported cash capex by the same amount, CFO minus cash capex does not change. Other adjustments or other definitions of FCF can produce different results.
The first disclosure, committee capitalization subtotal, wider line-cost adjustments, and broader estimate of income overstatement measure different things. See the disclosure and restatement comparison before quoting a total.
No. It can reflect genuine investment and varies with the business and the timing of projects. The useful question is whether the size and timing of reported spending fit the assets or projects the company describes.
Sources
- WorldCom Special Investigative Committee, Report of Investigation (March 31, 2003), §§ III.C and IV.A–D.
- WorldCom, FY 2002 Form 10-K (filed March 12, 2004), Item 7, F-5, F-8 and Notes 1, 2 and 4.
- Financial Accounting Standards Board, Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 95: Statement of Cash Flows, historical guidance, paragraphs 15, 17(c), and 21–23.
- SEC Division of Corporation Finance, Non-GAAP Financial Measures interpretations, Questions 102.07 (2016) and 103.01 (2010).
- WorldCom, June 25, 2002 announcement, Form 8-K Exhibit 99.1.
- SEC, Original civil complaint in SEC v. WorldCom (filed June 26, 2002), paragraphs 1–9.
- U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, Opinion and Order approving the settlement (July 7, 2003), opening discussion.
- WorldCom, original FY 2001 Form 10-K (filed March 13, 2002), F-4 and F-6.
- U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, Final Judgment as to Monetary Relief (July 7, 2003), preamble and Part I.
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, United States v. Ebbers, 458 F.3d 110 (July 28, 2006).
- U.S. Congress, H.R. 3763 as introduced (February 14, 2002).
- U.S. Congress, Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, Public Law 107-204 (July 30, 2002), §§ 101, 302 and 404.
Educational Use
This U.S. historical case study is for education. It does not provide accounting, legal or investment advice.
