Surety and Performance Bonds: Who Pays When a Contractor Defaults?

Table of Contents

    A contractor stops work halfway through a renovation. The owner needs someone to finish the job, and a supplier is still waiting to be paid for materials already delivered. Those are two different problems. A performance bond can help the owner finish the bonded work or recover covered losses from a qualifying default. A payment bond protects eligible providers of labor and materials. Both are types of surety bonds; a bid bond addresses an earlier risk, when the winning bidder must sign the contract and furnish the required bonds. [1] [2]

    What Is a Surety Bond?

    A construction surety bond is a guarantee that backs a specific obligation of a contractor. To understand who owes what, read three documents separately: the construction contract, the bond and any indemnity agreement. The contract sets the work and payment terms, the bond sets the surety’s promise, and the indemnity agreement can give the surety a right to recover money from the contractor and other signers. [1] [5] [7]

    Principal, Obligee and Surety
    • Principal: The contractor whose obligation the bond backs. The contractor still owes performance or payment under the underlying agreement.
    • Obligee: The party to whom the bond is given, often the project owner on a prime contract. On a payment bond, eligible suppliers or subcontractors can have claim rights even though the owner is the named obligee.
    • Surety: The party that backs the contractor’s obligation and responds under the bond’s terms. This is usually a surety company, though federal rules also allow qualifying individuals. The surety does not become the original contractor by signing the bond.

    These roles follow the contract. If a general contractor requires its electrical subcontractor to furnish a bond, the subcontractor can be the principal and the general contractor the obligee. [1] [2]

    Bid, Performance and Payment Bonds Compared

    The right bond depends on what could go wrong. A missing bond at award, an unfinished building and an unpaid invoice involve different obligations, even when they arise on the same job. [1] [2] [3]

    What each construction bond protects
    Bond When it matters What it backs
    Bid bond Bid and award The successful bidder’s obligation to sign the required documents and furnish required bonds. Depending on the terms, the owner can use the guarantee to offset the extra cost of awarding the work elsewhere.
    Performance bond Performance of the awarded contract The contractor’s work under the bonded contract. If a qualifying default occurs, a remedy may involve completing the agreed scope or paying a covered completion loss.
    Payment bond Unpaid bills for labor or materials on the bonded work The contractor’s payment obligations to eligible claimants. Who qualifies, when notice is due and which costs count depend on the bond and applicable law.

    The penal sum is the stated amount of the bond. It generally limits the surety’s liability under that bond, subject to its terms and applicable law. It is neither the fee to obtain the bond nor the amount due on every claim. The performance and payment bonds can carry separate amounts and protect different parties. The contractor’s own liability under the construction contract is a separate question. [1] [2] [5]

    When Are Construction Bonds Required?

    For covered construction, alteration or repair of U.S. federal public buildings or works, the Miller Act and the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) set the framework for performance and payment protection. FAR Part 28 also provides for alternative payment protections in particular procurements. A bid guarantee is specified separately; where permitted, a bid bond is one way to provide it. Check the actual solicitation for the required form, amount, acceptable security, due date and applicable agency deviations. When the federal construction bond clause applies, executed bonds are due within the time specified under the solicitation or by the contracting officer and before work starts. [1] [3] [4]

    On a state or local public project, start with the law for that jurisdiction and the procurement documents. On a private project, read the owner’s or lender’s requirements and the signed contract and bond, together with applicable law. A federal form or deadline should not be assumed to carry over. The guide to commercial risks in project finance explains where contractor completion risk fits alongside operating and revenue risk. [1] [5]

    How a Performance Bond Claim Works

    A late milestone may warrant a conversation, a notice or a cure period. Whether it triggers a bond remedy depends on the contract, the bond and what has happened on the job. The standard AIA A312–2010 performance bond illustrates why the sequence matters. If the owner is not in default, the form calls for the owner to tell both the contractor and the surety that it is considering declaring a contractor default. The next steps are to declare the default, terminate the contract, notify the surety and agree to make the remaining contract balance available as prescribed. Under that form, missing the initial notice affects the surety’s obligation only to the extent it shows actual prejudice. That qualification addresses the initial notice, not all the other steps. [5]

    Once its obligations are triggered, a surety may arrange for the original contractor to finish with the owner’s consent, take over completion, or arrange for a replacement contractor. The A312 form also allows the surety to give up those completion options, investigate the claim and pay the amount it determines it owes or explain why it denies the claim in whole or in part. The owner cannot assume that a claim triggers an immediate check or that it can hire a replacement first and send the surety the bill afterward. [5]

    A takeover in practice: A July 2026 federal district court order describes a Florida construction project where Hemmer Construction was the principal, Travelers the surety and Genesis IPV Properties the original obligee. Following a default declaration and termination in July 2023, the obligee demanded that Travelers respond under the performance and payment bonds. In March 2024, Travelers entered a takeover agreement to complete the work through another general contractor. The court later ordered the indemnitors to post collateral in a preliminary injunction. That order did not set the final loss. [6]

    Worked Example: Who Pays to Finish a $2 Million Job?

    Hypothetical Private Renovation

    Northline Builders wins a $2,000,000 renovation contract. The developer is the obligee. At bidding, a bid bond backs Northline’s obligation to sign and supply the required bonds if selected. Northline does both. When work starts, there is a $1,000,000 performance bond and a separate $2,000,000 payment bond. These are assumed private contract terms.

    The developer has already paid Northline $1,200,000 when Northline defaults. Assume the price has not changed, all of the remaining contract balance is available, and a replacement contractor will finish the same scope for $1,050,000. The developer satisfies the bond’s claim conditions, and the surety accepts and funds the full covered shortfall. There are no other damages or offsets in this calculation. [5]

    How the developer and surety fund the remaining work
    Amount Calculation
    Contract balance the developer contributes $2,000,000 − $1,200,000 = $800,000
    Covered completion shortfall the surety funds $1,050,000 − $800,000 = $250,000

    The developer still contributes the money already budgeted for the unfinished work. The $1,000,000 performance bond does not create a $1,000,000 payout. If Northline also owes an eligible supplier $60,000 for prior deliveries excluded from the replacement price, the supplier may pursue that amount separately under the payment bond. The $60,000 invoice is not part of the $250,000 completion shortfall. [2] [5]

    Indemnity: What the Contractor May Owe the Surety

    The surety’s promise to the owner and the contractor’s promise to the surety run in different directions. Under a general agreement of indemnity, or GAI, the contractor and any other signers who agree to be indemnitors may have to reimburse the surety for bond payments and expenses specified in that agreement. For example, if Northline’s surety funds the $250,000 shortfall and incurs $25,000 of professional expenses that the GAI covers, it could seek $250,000 + $25,000 = $275,000 for the performance side, assuming no other losses, recoveries or credits. The example does not count the supplier invoice as a surety loss. [7]

    Collateral is different from reimbursement. A signed GAI can allow a surety to demand security for expected losses before it has paid the claim. Paying the bond premium does not satisfy that obligation. Check who actually signed, in what capacity, which bonds the agreement reaches, what expenses it covers and what triggers a collateral demand. A business owner who signs personally as an indemnitor can put personal assets at risk. [6] [7]

    Funding without takeover: In March 2024, Shimmick and certain Berkshire Hathaway sureties signed an agreement to make limited funds available to help finish bonded contracts. The indemnitors reaffirmed their obligations to the sureties. The agreement illustrates another possible response to trouble on a bonded job: a surety can agree to finance completion while preserving its right to seek reimbursement. It is a historical agreement, not a commitment a contractor can count on. [8]

    Performance Bond vs. Standby Letter of Credit and Insurance

    Three ways to protect against different construction risks
    Instrument What prompts a response What it can provide
    Performance bond A qualifying contractor default and satisfaction of the bond’s claim conditions. Completion arrangements or payment of covered loss, depending on the bond. The surety may seek repayment from indemnitors. [5] [7]
    Standby letter of credit A timely presentation of the documents required by the credit, under its governing rules and law. A bank payment to the named beneficiary up to the available amount. The bank does not arrange completion; its right to reimbursement from the applicant is separate. [9]
    Commercial insurance A claim that meets the policy’s coverage terms, such as a covered property loss or third-party injury. Policy benefits subject to exclusions, deductibles and limits. Property or general liability insurance does not by itself guarantee a contractor’s performance. [10]

    An irrevocable letter of credit can serve as an alternative payment protection in certain federal procurements or secure a bond under FAR 28.204-3. In the second case, the bond remains in place. If a private contract allows a standby instead of a performance bond, check who can draw, what documents are needed and when it expires. A dollar-for-dollar match does not make the remedies equivalent. In futures markets, a “performance bond” is margin collateral for a trading position. [1] [9] [11]

    What to Check Before Signing or Filing a Claim

    • Owners: Verify the legal names, contract reference, form, acceptable surety, penal sum and deadline for each bond. To assess completion risk, stress-test the cost of finishing against the available contract balance, and budget for funding and schedule disruption while a claim is resolved. Read the default and notice requirements before acting.
    • Contractors: Discuss capacity for this job and your existing workload with the surety before bidding. Provide the requested financial and project information, get a premium quote and read the indemnity and collateral terms before signing. Eligible small businesses can ask about the SBA’s Surety Bond Guarantee program. The participating surety issues the bond, and the SBA provides a guarantee to the surety. [7] [12]
    • Subcontractors and suppliers: Obtain the payment bond, verify your place in the contracting chain and keep orders, delivery records, invoices and dates of last work. Identify the required recipients, delivery method and deadlines for notices and separate legal deadlines. A conversation about an overdue invoice may not satisfy a notice requirement.

    Under the Miller Act, check eligibility before counting days. A supplier can qualify if it contracts directly with the prime or with a first-tier subcontractor (one hired directly by the prime to perform part of the prime contract). A supplier that sells only to a lower-tier subcontractor or to a vendor that merely resells materials to the prime cannot use the prime’s Miller Act payment bond on the strength of that relationship alone. Sending a notice on time does not make an ineligible claimant eligible. [3] [13]

    For covered federal payment bonds, 40 U.S.C. § 3133 distinguishes three clocks. An eligible claimant may sue if it has not been paid in full after 90 days from the date it last furnished labor or material for the claim. A claimant that contracts directly with a first-tier subcontractor and has no contractual relationship with the prime must give the prime written notice within 90 days of the last labor or material for the claim, using a method the statute allows. Suit must be filed no later than one year after the claimant last furnished labor or material. Check the actual facts and governing law promptly; these deadlines are specific to covered federal payment bonds. [3] [13]

    Common Mistakes

    • Counting the whole bond amount as available cash. The stated amount tells you the size of the bond, not what the surety owes on a claim.
    • Using one bond to solve both problems. The owner’s unfinished work and a supplier’s unpaid bill have separate claim paths. Identify which obligation produced each cost before adding up a loss.
    • Treating a missed milestone like an automatic default. Check what the contract and bond require before a termination, replacement or demand.

    What a Performance Bond Does Not Cover Automatically

    Separate the Bond From the Project Budget

    A completion claim starts with the bonded work. A redesign, an elective upgrade or the owner’s lost rent during a delay may be real costs, but the bond does not automatically pay them. Read the incorporated contract, damage provisions and applicable law to determine which amounts are recoverable. Keep contingencies for costs and delays the bond may not address. [2] [5]

    Frequently Asked Questions

    The contractor generally pays a premium for issuing the bond. It depends on the surety’s evaluation of the contractor and the specific job and bond. An actual quote is more useful than a generic rate, and the premium is separate from the penal sum and any collateral. [7]

    Potentially. Payment to the general contractor is different from payment to the supplier. Under a federal Miller Act payment bond, for example, a qualifying unpaid supplier can have rights under the bond if it satisfies the governing requirements. Eligibility, notice and filing deadlines still matter. [2] [3]

    It can if the bond’s terms reach a warranty obligation. Federal Standard Form 25, for example, addresses performance through the life of a guaranty required by the contract. On a particular job, verify which warranty duties are bonded and when to give notice or make a claim. [2]

    Sources

    1. U.S. General Services Administration: FAR Part 28, Bonds and Insurance, including §§ 28.001, 28.101, 28.102, 28.203-1 and 28.204-3; FAR 52.228-1, Bid Guarantee.
    2. U.S. General Services Administration: Standard Form 25, Performance Bond; Standard Form 25A, Payment Bond; and Standard Form 24, Bid Bond.
    3. Office of the Law Revision Counsel: 40 U.S.C. § 3131, Bonds Required; § 3132, Alternatives; § 3133, Claimant Rights; and § 3134, Waivers.
    4. U.S. General Services Administration: FAR 52.228-15, Performance and Payment Bonds—Construction and the FAR Part 28 model deviation guide.
    5. AIA Contract Documents: A312–2010 Performance Bond sample, §§ 1–6 and A312–2010 form instructions.
    6. U.S. District Court, Middle District of Florida: Travelers v. Hemmer Construction, July 28, 2026 opinion and order, pp. 2–3 and 16–17.
    7. Travelers: General Agreement of Indemnity, SEC Exhibit 10.3, paragraphs 2–6, and surety underwriting and premium guidance.
    8. Shimmick Corporation: March 26, 2024 financing agreement, SEC Exhibit 10.9, recitals and sections 3–4.
    9. International Chamber of Commerce: International Standby Practices (ISP98), Rules 1.06–1.08 and 3.01; D.C. Law Library: D.C. Code § 28:5-108, Issuer’s Rights and Obligations.
    10. California Department of Insurance: Commercial Insurance Guide, commercial property and general liability sections.
    11. CME Group: Performance Bonds/Margins FAQ.
    12. U.S. Small Business Administration: Surety Bond Guarantee program.
    13. U.S. Supreme Court: J. W. Bateson Co. v. United States ex rel. Board of Trustees, 434 U.S. 586, 590–594 (1978); Clifford F. MacEvoy Co. v. United States ex rel. Calvin Tomkins Co., 322 U.S. 102, 107–111 (1944).

    Disclaimer: This article is for general education and does not provide legal advice or recommend a specific bond. For an actual bid, default or unpaid invoice, consult the governing documents and ask qualified counsel about applicable law and deadlines.