Buy-Sell Agreements: Funding a Buyout
Table of Contents
If your business partner dies, someone may need to buy their shares before the business can move forward under one owner. Will that buyer be you or the company? The answer determines who needs cash at closing, who should receive the insurance proceeds, and which shares you will own afterward.
Buy-sell agreements set the terms for an ownership transfer when specified events occur. Life or disability buyout insurance can fund part or all of the payment. This guide compares the two structures for a closely held U.S. business, with federal tax details illustrated for a C corporation. For the broader founder and investor exit context, see entrepreneurial finance.
What a Buy-Sell Agreement Controls
The agreement identifies the buyer, seller, trigger, price and payment terms. The insurance policy determines its own coverage, payee and claims process. An insurance payout does not transfer ownership, and an agreement can require a buyout even when no policy pays. [1] [2] [3]
For each trigger, specify whether the purchase is mandatory or gives someone an option. If the first buyer declines, who can buy next? If nobody exercises an option, who can hold the shares? A right of first refusal on a proposed outside sale, for instance, gives the designated buyer a chance to match the offer. It does not generally promise the owner an immediate exit. [2] [4]
- Death: Identify who can sign for the seller, who gets notice, and the deadlines to price and close the transfer. Coordinate the agreement with the owner’s wills, trusts and estate plan.
- Disability: Define the required degree and duration of disability, what evidence is needed, and who can run the business while the owner is away. Compare those terms with the insurer’s separate claim requirements.
- Retirement or departure: Specify whether notice, a termination date or another event starts the process. Set payment terms that the buyer can meet without a death or disability benefit.
- Divorce, bankruptcy or another involuntary transfer: Ask counsel what purchase rights are enforceable and how to handle notice and deadlines under applicable law. Listing the event does not determine the rights of a spouse, creditor or trustee. [2] [4]
Cross-Purchase vs. Entity Redemption
Start with the party who actually owes the seller money. In a simple cross-purchase, the remaining owner buys the departing owner’s shares. In an entity redemption, the corporation buys back its own shares. In both structures the survivor can end up with a larger ownership percentage, but only the cross-purchase in the example below gives the survivor a new block of purchased shares. [1]
| Decision | Cross-purchase | Entity redemption |
|---|---|---|
| Who buys the shares? | The surviving owner buys them directly. | The corporation buys its own shares. Those shares are no longer outstanding. |
| Who funds the insured death buyout? | In a simple two-owner design, each owner owns, pays for and is beneficiary of a policy on the other. | The company owns, pays for and is beneficiary of a policy on each covered owner. |
| Who needs cash beyond insurance? | The buyer needs personal funds or financing. Premium affordability may differ by owner. | The company needs available funds and must be able to make a lawful redemption. |
| What happens to the survivor’s stock basis? | The new shares generally start with cost basis; the existing shares are a separate lot. | No personal share purchase, so no purchase-price addition to the basis of existing shares. |
Either arrangement can use two policies when there are two owners. A direct cross-purchase becomes harder to administer when each of several owners must insure each of the others. A hybrid agreement can offer the owners a first option and then require the corporation to buy if they decline, as the agreement in Connelly did. Check where the insurance cash goes in each branch. A policy payable to the company does not put cash directly in a shareholder’s hands to exercise a personal purchase option. [1] [5] [6]
How the Agreement Sets the Buyout Price
A fixed price is easy to apply but can go stale. Give it an expiration date and specify a fallback if the owners miss the update. A formula can use a multiple of earnings, revenue or another defined measure. Specify the accounting period and how to treat owner pay, one-time items, debt, cash and insurance. An independent appraisal can account for changes the formula misses. Specify who hires the appraiser, the valuation date, the valuation standard and how to resolve competing valuations. The fundamental analysis guide covers broader valuation methods. [1] [4] [7]
Ask whether the agreement values the entire company and allocates the result, or values the specific interest. Different voting or economic rights can matter. A contract can prescribe a simple percentage for closing while a separate tax appraisal considers control and restrictions on selling closely held shares. Do not assume an appraisal must apply a discount or that the insurer’s benefit equals the agreed price. [3] [8]
A real contract example: In its October 2023 annual report, Thirty Three Threads, Inc. described a repurchase formula for specified exits involving two owners: 1.5 times the prior 12 months’ net revenue, divided by fully diluted shares for a per-share price. It also described a note paid in 10 equal annual installments if death proceeds fell short. The formula set the price; the policy and the note addressed payment. The filing describes that agreement at that time. [4]
Worked Example: One Buyout Price, Two Buyers
In this hypothetical example, Alice owns 60 of 100 common shares and Ben owns 40. Ben’s 40 shares have $100,000 of adjusted tax basis. The agreement values operations at six times normalized EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, adjusted as the agreement specifies), adds excess cash and subtracts debt. It explicitly leaves the death benefit out of the pricing formula. Alice dies; a policy on Alice pays $1 million and the full amount is available at closing. Assume no transaction costs and no other basis changes.
- Operations: $400,000 normalized EBITDA × 6 = $2.4 million.
- Contractual equity value: $2.4 million + $300,000 excess cash − $700,000 debt = $2 million.
- Alice’s contract price: 60% × $2 million = $1.2 million.
- Remaining cash needed: $1.2 million − $1 million = $200,000. Assume the actual buyer can supply that cash.
Cross-purchase: The carrier pays Ben $1 million. Ben adds $200,000 of his cash and pays Alice’s estate $1.2 million in exchange for 60 shares. He now owns 100 of 100 shares. His old shares retain their $100,000 basis; his new shares begin with $1.2 million cost basis, for $1.3 million in total across both lots. The corporation does not receive this policy payout. [1] [5]
Entity redemption: The carrier pays the corporation $1 million. It adds $200,000 of lawfully available corporate cash, pays Alice’s estate $1.2 million and retires those 60 shares. Ben now owns 40 of the 40 outstanding shares and still has $100,000 of basis. He acquired no additional shares. Holding the other inputs fixed, the company’s illustrative equity after paying is $2 million + $1 million − $1.2 million = $1.8 million. That is an after-payment calculation. [1] [5] [6]
The estate’s stock basis is a separate question: shares acquired from a decedent generally take fair market value at death as basis, subject to exceptions. This adjustment is to the inherited shares; it does not by itself change the company’s asset basis. A qualifying corporate redemption can receive sale or exchange treatment. If it does not qualify, it is generally a corporate distribution under the applicable rules. Have a tax adviser check attribution rules, which can treat a seller as owning shares indirectly. S corporation pass-through adjustments and partnership-taxed LLCs require their own analysis. [5] [9]
Why Estate Value Can Differ From the Price
In Connelly v. United States (June 6, 2024), Crown C Supply redeemed Michael Connelly’s shares for $3 million using life insurance proceeds. An appraisal prepared during the audit excluded the $3 million earmarked for the redemption. The IRS added it to the $3.86 million valuation, yielding $6.86 million for the company and about $5.3 million for Michael’s 77.18% interest ($6.86 million × 77.18%). The Supreme Court held that Crown’s obligation to redeem the shares at fair market value did not itself reduce their value. The estate valuation looked at the shares at death, before the company paid out the cash. [1] [8]
The Court did not rule that a redemption obligation can never affect value. It noted that having to sell operating assets to fund the redemption could reduce future earning capacity. The federal valuation rule also calls for considering company-payable life proceeds to the extent they have not already been counted. Do not add them twice or assume a matching redemption obligation will automatically cancel them. [1] [8]
Return to Alice and Ben. Separately assume the appraiser starts from $2 million of company equity before the death benefit, values the stake proportionally and makes no other adjustments. Under cross-purchase, an illustrative at-death stake value is 60% × $2 million = $1.2 million. Under entity redemption, the company is entitled to $1 million, giving 60% × ($2 million + $1 million) = $1.8 million before closing. The latter $1.8 million is the modeled value of Alice’s 60% stake at death; the coincidentally equal $1.8 million above is the modeled value of the whole company after payout. The $600,000 difference between the two at-death estimates is not tax due. [1] [8]
Federal transfer-tax rules generally disregard below-market purchase rights and certain restrictions on selling or using property unless the terms meet all three tests in Section 2703: a bona fide business arrangement, no device to transfer property to the decedent’s family for less than full and adequate consideration, and terms comparable to arm’s-length deals. Even when a restriction can be considered, the facts and applicable valuation rules still matter. [8] [10]
What Life and Disability Buyout Insurance Fund
Life insurance: cash for a death-triggered purchase
Check the policy owner, insured person, beneficiary, premium payer and net benefit available at closing. A $1 million benefit does not establish the buyout price, and a policy that expires before the ownership obligation ends can leave the buyer with no coverage. Plan for claim delays and changed ownership or business value. Evaluate family life insurance needs as a separate budget. Key-person coverage is designed to support the business after the loss of an important worker; cash committed to a share purchase cannot also replace operating income. [1] [11]
Life insurance death proceeds are generally excluded from federal gross income. A transfer of an existing policy for value can limit that exclusion, so have counsel check the transfer-for-value and reportable-policy-sale rules before changing owners. [12]
Section 101(j) generally applies to employer-owned life insurance contracts issued after August 17, 2006. For an older contract, a qualifying Section 1035 exchange can preserve the earlier treatment. A material increase in the death benefit or another material change can cause the contract to be treated as newly issued. Check the issue date and any exchanges or material changes when deciding whether the rule and annual Form 8925 reporting apply. [12] [13]
When Section 101(j) applies, it generally limits the exclusion to premiums and other amounts the policyholder paid for the contract. Its exceptions require that the notice and consent rules be satisfied, generally in writing before issuance, and that the insured meets a status test or the proceeds are paid or used in a qualifying way. For example, proceeds the company uses to buy shares from the insured’s estate can qualify to the extent used for that purchase by the due date, including extensions, of the company’s return for the year it receives the benefit for tax purposes. This income-tax rule does not decide the estate value of stock. [12] [13]
Disability buyout insurance: cash after a qualifying disability
A disability buyout policy can fund a purchase while the departing owner is alive. The insurer applies the policy’s disability definition and elimination period, the required wait before benefits can be payable. Compare the two documents for medical proof, eligible purchase amount, exclusions, limits and lump-sum or installment timing. Personal disability income insurance addresses the worker’s lost income. Disability buyout coverage addresses the buyer’s cost of acquiring ownership. [3]
Timing test: In a separate hypothetical disability scenario, a $1.2 million purchase is due 90 days after onset, but the policy requires at least 180 days from the same qualifying onset. At closing, $1.2 million − $0 insurance available = $1.2 million to fund from other sources. If the insurer later pays $1 million, the remaining overall shortfall is $200,000 before financing costs. Day 180 is the end of the assumed wait, not a promise of payment on that date. Before transferring shares on day 90, ask the insurer how the policy treats a claim when the buyout closes before the waiting period ends. Some policies can end coverage when the insured stops owning shares or the buy-sell agreement is carried out. If no benefit is payable, the buyer must fund the full $1.2 million. Agree on a funding plan before signing a contract with the earlier deadline. [3]
How to Evaluate a Buy-Sell Agreement
- Run each trigger in both directions. List who can sign, who must buy or may decline, who votes in the interim and what happens when neither owner can act.
- Write the price calculation on one page. Identify the date, profit measure, adjustments and treatment of proceeds. Check the result against a recent independent appraisal or another valuation method appropriate to the business. [7]
- Test liquidity at the contractual deadline. Subtract the cash and net insurance proceeds the buyer can actually use at closing from the cash due. Test a delay or denied claim. Decide whether a reserve, a committed credit line or an agreed installment note covers the difference. With a note, address interest, security and the seller’s risk of nonpayment. Verify that a corporate payment is allowed under applicable law and financing covenants. Delaware’s capital-impairment limits are one example. [3] [4] [6]
- Review after a material change. Revisit the price, policies, beneficiaries and funding when ownership, profits, debt or health changes. Discuss the agreement with business and estate counsel, and have the tax adviser and insurance professional check the matching terms before policies are issued or transferred. [12] [13]
Keep the agreement, signed price updates, policy ownership and beneficiary records, and funding plan together. Give the people who would execute the agreement access to those records.
Common Mistakes
- Funding face value instead of the closing obligation. Check who receives the benefit, what amount is payable and when the buyer can use it.
- Using yesterday’s agreement for today’s company. A stale formula or policy amount can shift value between buyer and seller or force borrowing.
- Comparing only immediate premiums. Compare the survivor’s stock basis, estate valuation exposure, lender restrictions, ongoing cash needs and responsibility for keeping each policy in force. [1] [5] [6]
What the Agreement Cannot Guarantee
Plan who will manage the business and how payroll, lenders and customers will be served during the transition. A purchase-price formula will not tell you how much operating cash must stay in the company. If buying shares leaves too little cash to run the business, revisit the funding and payment terms. [6] [11]
If either owner is uninsurable or coverage is too costly, model a smaller payment up front and the seller’s exposure on any deferred balance. A lower initial payment can protect operating cash, but it also makes the estate or departing owner depend on the buyer’s ability to pay later. The payment plan should work for both sides. [4]
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
- U.S. Supreme Court, Connelly v. United States, 602 U.S. 257 (2024), slip op. pp. 1–9 and n.2.
- Axialnics Systems, Inc., Shareholders’ Agreement, July 25, 2019, arts. 1–2 and 4–7 (SEC filing exhibit).
- Insurance Compact, Individual Disability Income Buy-Sell Policy Standards, effective July 10, 2023.
- Thirty Three Threads, Inc., Form C-AR, dated October 28, 2023, pp. 34–35.
- 26 U.S.C. § 1012 and § 1014, cost basis and property acquired from a decedent.
- 8 Del. C. § 160(a)(1) and Delaware Supreme Court, SV Investment Partners v. ThoughtWorks, Nov. 15, 2011.
- U.S. Small Business Administration, Manage Your Business, valuation and sale guidance.
- 26 CFR § 20.2031-2 and 26 U.S.C. § 2033, closely held stock valuation and property interests at death.
- 26 U.S.C. § 302, federal redemption treatment, and IRS Form 7203 instructions, S corporation basis adjustments.
- 26 U.S.C. § 2703, transfer-tax treatment of specified rights and restrictions.
- Insurance Compact, Individual Disability Income Key Person Replacement Insurance Policy Standards.
- 26 U.S.C. § 101, life insurance death benefits, transfers for value and employer-owned contracts.
- IRS Notice 2009-48 and Form 8925 instructions, employer-owned life insurance.
Disclaimer
This article provides U.S. educational information as of November 17, 2026. It is not legal, tax, valuation or insurance advice. Outcomes depend on the entity, state law, applicable tax rules, agreement and policy. Consult qualified advisers before signing or funding a buy-sell agreement.
