Your result
Present-value cost advantage
$229.59 Keeping, over 12 months
Keeping costs $229.59 less in present value over 12 months; the lower refinance payment leaves more debt.
Out of date: fix the highlighted field to update.
- Current monthly payment
- $1,280.62
- Principal and interest
- Refinance monthly payment
- $533.78
- Principal and interest
- Refinance nominal saving
- −$401.92
- Over 12 months; negative = costlier
- Refinance PV saving
- −$229.59
- At 4.0% effective annual opportunity rate
- Current loan debt at horizon
- $7,422
- At month 12, after payment
- Refinance debt at horizon
- $16,786
- At month 12, after payment
Refinancing leaves more debt at month 12
Both paths keep the same car for 12 months; payments stop after payoff.
Month-end debt after each scheduled payment; monthly fixed-rate approximation.
Show the data table
The chart could not load. The table above has every value.
Compare costs over the same holding period
| Component | Keep loan | Refinance |
|---|
Show the math
- New loan balance
- Cash at closing
- Nominal comparison
- Present-value comparison
- Equal resources
Understanding auto refinance
What the result means
The cost advantage tells you which loan uses fewer resources over your chosen holding period. It includes the debt still owed after the final payment in that period. The headline is a positive amount with the lower-cost path named beside it. Signed refinance savings remain below it: a negative saving means refinancing costs more. Both paths keep the same car, so its value cannot create a refinance advantage.
How it is calculated
First, calculate each monthly principal-and-interest payment. Refinance borrowing pays off the old principal and separately accrued interest, plus only the charges you choose to finance. Any remaining charges are paid at closing. Add payments through the horizon and the debt left then, and subtract the same car value. That is nominal cost. Present value discounts every future payment and the terminal debt minus value using your entered effective annual opportunity rate.
Both paths start with the same cash and receive the same monthly budget, the larger of the two regular payments. Unspent cash stays available and grows at the opportunity-rate assumption, including after a loan is repaid. The table shows this retained cash and terminal wealth as an equivalent view. Do not add its advantage to the PV saving; they express the same difference at different dates.
Worked example
Suppose the current principal is $21,000 at a 12% annual note rate with 18 months remaining. Its monthly payment is $1,280.62. A refinance at 9% for 48 months finances a $450 fee, borrowing $21,450 with a $533.78 monthly payment and no closing cash. Over a 12-month holding period, the payment falls by $746.84, but the current loan ends with $7,422 of debt versus $16,786 after refinancing.
Including those debts and the same $14,000 car value, refinancing costs $401.92 more in nominal dollars. At an assumed 4% effective annual opportunity rate, keeping costs $229.59 less in present value. The longer new term defers principal repayment; it does not erase the debt.
What changes the result most
A lower note rate reduces interest, while a longer term can increase the amount owed at your exit date. Fees matter most over short horizons. Financing a fee changes both its timing and the interest charged on it. A higher opportunity rate gives more value to delayed payments, so the PV result can differ in direction from nominal cost. It is a sensitivity assumption, not a promised investment return.
Limits and assumptions
This is an unrounded monthly fixed-rate illustration, with the first new payment one month after closing. Actual lenders may accrue interest daily, round payments to cents, impose prepayment terms or change payment dates. Precomputed-interest, variable-rate and irregular loans, cash-out, fee refunds and unknown payoff breakdowns are outside the model. Confirm the note rate separately from APR, which may already reflect fees. For purchase financing, use the Auto Loan Calculator.
The current principal excludes accrued interest. If you add accrued interest, also enter a documented fixed payment and verify that the monthly timing matches the contract. An inclusive payoff quote is not principal plus the same interest again. The documented payment overrides the remaining-term payment estimate and continues until payoff; the terminal balance is retained if it remains unpaid at the horizon.
Transaction taxes are entered quote amounts, not nationwide rules. Results exclude income-tax benefits, including the federal vehicle-loan-interest deduction; this does not mean that a deduction is unavailable. Car value is your same-car scenario, not an appraisal. Common fuel, insurance and maintenance costs cancel because refinancing alone does not change the car or use period. Figures are rounded for display, so displayed components can differ slightly from displayed totals.
Frequently asked questions
Does a lower monthly payment mean refinancing saves money?
How are upfront and financed fees treated?
What does present value mean here?
Why does changing the car value leave the saving unchanged?
Can I enter an actual payoff quote?
Are income-tax deductions included?
Sources
- CFPB: Simple interest and precomputed auto-loan interest (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
- FTC: Buying a used car from a dealer (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
Explore related calculators

