Your result
Annual scenario cost difference
$320.00 Option A costs less this year
Option A costs $320.00 less for this year with one modeled loss, including premiums and your share of the loss.
Out of date: fix the highlighted field to update.
- Annual premium difference
- $180.00
- Option B saves per year
- Extra cash per loss with B
- $500.00
- Versus Option A, per modeled loss
- Option B cash per loss
- $1,000.00
- After modeled insurer payment
See what each loss leaves you to pay
| Per loss | Option A | Option B |
|---|---|---|
| Deductible retained within cap | $500.00 | $1,000.00 |
| Loss above vehicle cap | $0.00 | $0.00 |
| Insurer payment | $2,500.00 | $2,000.00 |
| Your cash per modeled loss | $500.00 | $1,000.00 |
Annual costs change with loss events
| Loss events in one year | Option A total | Option B total | Lower scenario cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | $1,200.00 | $1,020.00 | Option B by $180.00 |
| 1 (selected) | $1,700.00 | $2,020.00 | Option A by $320.00 |
| 2 | $2,200.00 | $3,020.00 | Option A by $820.00 |
Show the math
- Amount within the cap
- min($3,000.00, $20,000.00) = $3,000.00 per loss
- Payout per loss
- A: max($3,000.00 − $500.00, $0.00) = $2,500.00; B: max($3,000.00 − $1,000.00, $0.00) = $2,000.00
- Cash per loss
- A: $3,000.00 − $2,500.00 = $500.00; B: $3,000.00 − $2,000.00 = $1,000.00
- One-year scenario costs
- A: $1,200.00 + 1 × $500.00 = $1,700.00; B: $1,020.00 + 1 × $1,000.00 = $2,020.00
- Annual difference
- $2,020.00 − $1,700.00 = $320.00; Option A costs less this year
Understanding the deductible tradeoff
What the result means
The annual difference combines the premium with your share of each modeled loss. It describes the scenario you entered. A smaller annual total does not establish which deductible fits your finances.
How it is calculated
First limit the loss to the vehicle cap, then subtract the deductible with a zero floor. Your cash burden is the full entered loss less that insurance payment. Multiply your cash per loss by the number of separate events, then add the annual premium.
Worked example
In this hypothetical example, Option A has a $1,200 annual premium and a $500 deductible. Option B has a $1,020 annual premium and a $1,000 deductible. For one $3,000 loss below the $20,000 vehicle cap, you pay $500 with A or $1,000 with B. Annual totals are $1,700 and $2,020: A costs $320 less in that scenario. With no loss, B costs $180 less for the year.
What changes the result most
The actual premium difference is paid each year. The extra deductible cash is paid for each separate covered event. A loss below both deductibles may leave both options paying nothing. A low vehicle value can also limit both payouts, so the deductible difference alone can overstate the extra protection.
Limits and assumptions
Compare one coverage at a time with otherwise equivalent policies and the same pre-deductible vehicle cap. Actual contracts can have waivers, different valuation terms or other exceptions. Check the settlement wording with your insurer.
The event counts are hypothetical, with unchanged quotes and the same loss size each time. They do not predict claim frequency or repeated claims on a totaled vehicle. Taxes, fees, salvage, loan balances, premium changes after a claim and third-party recoveries are excluded. A loss above the cap is an entered repair or replacement target, not an insurer's valuation.
Cash per loss is your burden after the modeled insurer payment. If you pay first and are reimbursed later, temporary upfront cash can reach the full loss amount. Consider that timing alongside your emergency fund.
Frequently asked questions
Does this calculator estimate my insurance premium?
Does a higher deductible always save money?
Is the deductible paid once a year?
What should I use for the vehicle cap?
Why can the cash per loss exceed the deductible?
Are the loss events a claim forecast?
Sources
- Texas Department of Insurance · Auto insurance guide (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
- Progressive · Collision deductibles and vehicle value (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
- Washington WAC 284-30-391 · Total-loss settlement (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
- Texas Department of Insurance · Deductibles per claim (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
Explore related calculators

