Lower required payments can help cash flow, but do not establish savings. Both paths use your full monthly debt budget, including payment rollover, and count all debt still owed at your selected month. All extra principal must be permitted without penalties.
Existing debts and new quote
Your comparison
Enter your terms, then choose Compare consolidation.
- Nominal advantage
- —
- New loan required P&I
- —
- Old debts’ first-month minimums
- —
- Cash fee today
- —
| Measure | Keep existing | Consolidate |
|---|
Monthly payments and remaining debt
| Month | Old minimums | Old payment | New payment | Old interest | New interest | Old debt | New debt | PV advantage |
|---|
Existing debts: allocation and promo transitions
| Month | Debt | Current APR | Minimum | Actual payment | Ending balance |
|---|
How the consolidation comparison works
Replacing several debts with one payment can simplify repayment. Whether it saves money depends on rates, fees, repayment effort and debt remaining—not just the advertised monthly payment. This calculator compares all entered balances under two explicit strategies, with the same cash available today, same monthly budget and same holding period.
The keep-debt baseline: minimums plus avalanche
At the start of each month, interest is opening balance × annual rate ÷ 1,200. We reserve each installment loan’s original computed P&I payment and each card’s required minimum, capped at the amount due. Card minimums are either max(floor, opening balance × minimum percentage), or max(floor, interest + opening balance × minimum percentage). Pick the exact supported formula in your agreement; we do not infer an unknown issuer formula.
All remaining budget pays the highest current APR first. Equal rates use debt input row order. Any unused amount after paying off that debt moves to the next debt in the same month; future freed payments roll over. Card APR rankings update when promotions expire: N promo periods means the promo APR in months 1–N and regular APR from N+1. There is no retroactive interest. Payment covers interest before principal; unpaid interest remains in debt. If the budget cannot cover required payments in any modeled month, the comparison stops and identifies that month.
The consolidation path uses the same budget
The new loan principal is every active debt’s full balance plus financed fees. Cash fees are total fees less financed fees. Fixed required P&I is P × r ÷ [1 − (1+r)−n], where r is annual rate ÷ 1,200; at zero rate it is P ÷ n. Your budget must cover that payment. The entire extra budget reduces principal immediately with no prepayment penalty; after payoff, the unspent amount is retained. Extending the quoted term alone therefore never reduces the repayment effort in this comparison.
Both choices start with cash equal to the cash fee. Keeping retains that cash; consolidation spends it. Retained cash and unused end-month budget grow at your entered net effective annual opportunity rate. The headline instead discounts actual payments, cash fees and remaining debt to today at (1 + annual opportunity rate)month/12. These are equivalent ways to compare the same resources. Terminal advantage is the PV result expressed at your chosen month, not an extra investment benefit. At 0%, nominal advantage = old interest − new interest − all fees. Fees are never counted twice.
A zero-rate example you can verify
Keep a $500 card with a $100 minimum floor and a $500 loan with five $100 payments, both at 0%. With a $300 budget, equal-APR row order sends the extra $100 to the card. Existing total balances after months 1–4 are $700, $400, $100 and $0. A new 0% loan with a $30 financed fee starts at $1,030: balances are $730, $430, $130 and $0. At month 2, each has paid $600, but consolidation leaves $30 more debt. At month 4, old payments total $1,000 and new payments $1,030. Consolidation is $30 worse despite a lower required loan payment.
Supported terms and limitations
Use up to three ordinary debts with zero new spending, no arrears, payoff penalties, insurance or ongoing fees. Loans must be fixed-rate, fully amortizing monthly P&I obligations. Cards must have one APR bucket, one supported minimum formula and ordinary introductory APR terms. Deferred-interest arrangements, grace periods, mixed card APR buckets, daily-average-balance precision, exact statement dates and lender cent rounding are not modeled. Verify minimums, payoff amounts, net loan proceeds and penalty-free extra payments against actual statements and the quote.
Unsupported federal forgiveness/IDR, secured-loan collateral changes and tax effects do not receive a numerical benefit claim. This tool assumes all active debts are fully paid off by the new loan and the displayed note principal matches the actual quote; it does not model cash-out or silently omit leftover balances. It predicts neither loan approval nor credit-score changes.
Unpaid debt at the selected horizon is distinct from a nonamortizing budget. We establish nonamortization when all outstanding debts share the same continuing APR and the monthly budget does not exceed their interest; total debt then cannot decrease under those unchanged terms. With different APRs, avalanche payments can lower future interest even when total debt grows initially. Such growth alone does not establish that payoff is impossible; unpaid debt is reported at the selected horizon. Every balance, payment and accrued interest through that month remains in the comparison. Inputs allow $0.01–$1 million per active debt, APRs 0–50%, 1–480 loan/horizon months and 0–120 promo months. A projected opening debt above $10 million stops the model. Assumptions are scenarios, not guarantees.
