Skip to content

Personal finance · Health insurance

Health Insurance Plan Comparison Calculator

See how two quoted health plans compare at the same annual in-network allowed spending.

  • Formulas checked against sources
  • Updated November 2026
  • Free, no sign-up

Your inputs

Example values — change them to yours.
Shared scenario
Both quotes must cover the same individual for a full year, start with empty accumulators and apply one deductible then uniform coinsurance to the same allowed-spending bucket.
Use the same covered allowed amount for both plans; omit zero-cost preventive care and all services outside the declared design.
Plan A
Net take-home means the confirmed annual reduction in your take-home pay or after-tax cash, before any HSA credit.
Use your own quoted premium cost after employer premium subsidies, without deducting employer HSA funding.
The single in-network deductible that applies to every dollar in the modeled spending bucket.
Your share of allowed covered costs after the deductible, not the insurer's share.
The in-network medical limit including this deductible and coinsurance; premiums stay outside it.
Employer-funded money only; exclude employee salary reductions, earlier balances and any credit already in the premium.
Plan B
Use the same basis as Plan A; this calculator does not convert pre-tax deductions into take-home costs.
Use your own quoted premium cost after employer premium subsidies, without deducting employer HSA funding.
The single in-network deductible that applies to every dollar in the modeled spending bucket.
Your share of allowed covered costs after the deductible, not the insurer's share.
The in-network medical limit including this deductible and coinsurance; premiums stay outside it.
Enter zero when no employer-funded HSA contribution is confirmed for this quote.
Employer HSA assumptions
Are all positive employer HSA credits confirmed?
Confirm contribution eligibility, employer-only entitlement, qualified medical use and no double credit; the deductible alone does not establish eligibility.
Are the employer HSA funds available before bills?
Choose No when either plan's positive funding arrives later or its timing is unknown; annual HSA credit does not establish upfront cash needs.

Your result

Annual modeled cost difference

$700 Plan A costs less per year

At $12,000 of allowed spending, Plan A has $700 less modeled annual resource cost after confirmed employer HSA funding.

Plan A modeled resource cost
$7,400
Annual, net premium basis
Plan B modeled resource cost
$8,100
Annual, net premium basis
Caution:
A limited cost comparison
This comparison covers the declared medical design only. Employee HSA/FSA tax savings, premium tax conversion, networks, drug coverage and access are not evaluated.
Note:
HSA funding and household cash
With employer HSA funds available before bills and fully applied to eligible medical costs, annual household outlay is $7,400 for Plan A and $8,100 for Plan B; unused employer HSA assets are $0 for each plan. This is not a peak-cash schedule.

Premiums, medical costs and HSA resources

Annual amounts on the selected premium basis at the same allowed spending; raw pre-tax premiums are tax-unadjusted, and HSA-use rows assume full eligible use or reimbursement.
Annual componentPlan APlan B
Premium cost$3,600.00$6,000.00
Patient medical cost$4,800.00$2,100.00
Premiums plus medical before HSA$8,400.00$8,100.00
Employer HSA resource credit$1,000.00$0.00
Employer HSA applied to medical$1,000.00$0.00
Unused employer HSA asset$0.00$0.00
Household outlay after HSA use$7,400.00$8,100.00
Quoted medical out-of-pocket limit$6,850.00$4,500.00
Attainable maximum resource cost$9,450.00$10,500.00
Modeled resource cost$7,400.00$8,100.00

Show the math

Medical = min(M, min(S, D) + c × max(0, S − D)); modeled resource cost = P + medical − H
Plan A medical cost
min($6,850, $3,000 deductible + 20.00% × $9,000 after deductible) = $4,800.
Plan B medical cost
min($4,500, $1,000 deductible + 10.00% × $11,000 after deductible) = $2,100.
Plan A modeled resource cost
$3,600 premiums + $4,800 medical − $1,000 employer HSA funding = $7,400 per year.
Plan B modeled resource cost
$6,000 premiums + $2,100 medical − $0 employer HSA funding = $8,100 per year.
Annual modeled cost difference
$8,100 − $7,400 = $700 less modeled annual resource cost for Plan A at this spending.
S is the same covered in-network allowed spending, D is the deductible, c is the patient's coinsurance, M is the medical out-of-pocket limit, P is annual premium cost on the selected basis, and H is confirmed employer-funded HSA credit. Premiums stay outside M.

Understanding health plan costs

What the result means

The answer compares the modeled annual resource cost of two health plans at the same covered in-network allowed spending. Resource cost adds your premium and patient medical cost, then subtracts confirmed employer-funded health savings account (HSA) money. It helps isolate the cost trade-off in two actual quotes. A lower figure at one spending level is not a recommendation about the insurance contract, network, medicines or access to care.

How it is calculated

For the supported design, you pay covered allowed costs until the deductible is met. Your stated patient coinsurance then applies to remaining allowed costs, until the medical out-of-pocket limit caps that patient cost. Premiums are added separately because the medical limit does not include them. The math panel shows each plan's calculation with your inputs.

Employer HSA funding is a resource, not automatically a cash reimbursement. The table shows how much could pay or reimburse eligible medical costs and how much would remain as an unused HSA asset. Annual household outlay after that use can differ from resource cost. Earlier bills can still require cash when employer contributions arrive later. Ordinary premiums are not HSA-paid in this model.

Worked example

Suppose the hypothetical Plan A quote has annual net premiums of $3,600, a $3,000 deductible, 20% patient coinsurance, a $6,850 medical limit and $1,000 of confirmed employer HSA funding. Plan B has $6,000 of annual net premiums, a $1,000 deductible, 10% patient coinsurance, a $4,500 medical limit and no employer HSA funding.

At $12,000 of allowed spending, Plan A's medical cost is $3,000 plus 20% of the remaining $9,000, or $4,800. Plan B's medical cost is $1,000 plus 10% of $11,000, or $2,100. Plan A's modeled resource cost is $3,600 + $4,800 − $1,000 = $7,400 per year. Plan B's is $6,000 + $2,100 = $8,100 per year. The modeled annual difference is $700 in favor of Plan A at this spending.

What changes the result most

Premium differences matter even with no medical spending and continue after medical limits are reached. Deductibles and patient coinsurance change the medical costs between those points. Confirmed employer HSA funding reduces resource cost, but unused money remains an asset rather than a cash refund. A resource cost can be negative when that unused asset exceeds the modeled outlay. At zero patient coinsurance, a quoted medical limit above the deductible is never reached under this model.

Limits and assumptions

Use matching individual coverage for a full plan year, with empty starting accumulators. Hold the same allowed-dollar spending bucket fixed for both plans; this does not establish equal negotiated prices for the same care. Exclude zero-cost preventive services. Copays, deductible-exempt spending, separate prescription rules, family or embedded accumulators, midyear coverage and noncovered or out-of-network costs stop the comparison. The aggregate formula does not reproduce each insurer's claim-rounding rules.

Confirm HSA eligibility and employer-only entitlement separately; a high deductible alone does not establish eligibility. Employee salary reductions, employee HSA/FSA tax savings, existing HSA balances, tax deductions and marketplace-credit reconciliation are excluded. Prefer comparable net take-home premium costs. Matching raw pre-tax payroll deductions produce only a premium-tax-unadjusted illustration; unknown or mixed bases cannot be compared. Different cost curves may cross more than once, so no universal break-even level is supplied.

The HSA Savings Calculator explores supported HSA eligibility and savings scenarios. Use the Budget Planner Calculator and Emergency Fund Calculator for broader household cash planning.

Frequently asked questions

Which health plans can this calculator compare?
It compares matching individual coverage for a full plan year with empty starting accumulators. All entered covered in-network allowed spending must follow one deductible, then one uniform patient coinsurance rate, with one medical out-of-pocket limit. Copays, deductible-exempt services, separate prescription rules, family or embedded accumulators and midyear coverage are unsupported. Leave zero-cost preventive care out of the modeled spending bucket. Check each actual quote before choosing the supported design.
Do I enter the provider's bill or the allowed amount?
Enter the covered in-network allowed amount, which is the plan's negotiated or recognized amount for a service. The provider's billed charge may be different. This comparison holds the same allowed-spending amount fixed for both plans; it does not establish that their provider networks or negotiated rates are equal. Noncovered services, out-of-network costs and charges above the allowed amount are excluded.
Are premiums included in the out-of-pocket limit?
No. The modeled medical out-of-pocket limit caps the supported deductible and coinsurance costs. Annual premium costs are added separately, so reaching the medical limit does not eliminate premiums. The table keeps those amounts separate. A zero-coinsurance design may stop accumulating medical costs at the deductible and never reach a larger quoted medical limit.
How does employer HSA funding affect the comparison?
Confirmed employer-funded HSA money is an annual resource credit. The table separately shows the amount applied to eligible medical costs, the unused employer HSA asset and household outlay after that use. Unused HSA money remains an asset rather than becoming a cash refund. Employee salary-reduction contributions and earlier HSA balances do not create another employer resource credit. Eligibility and contribution entitlement must be confirmed separately.
Does the result include every tax benefit?
No. Use comparable user-supplied net take-home premium costs when available. Matching raw pre-tax payroll deductions can produce only an illustration explicitly unadjusted for premium tax effects; mixed or unknown premium bases stop the comparison. Employee HSA and FSA tax savings, tax deductions and marketplace-credit reconciliation are not calculated. The result is not a complete after-tax recommendation.
Can I use the difference as one universal break-even threshold?
No. The answer compares the two modeled annual resource costs only at your entered allowed spending. Different deductibles, coinsurance rates and medical limits can produce more than one crossing, no crossing or a tie over a range. This calculator does not solve for a break-even spending level or claim that the lower-cost option remains lower at every other spending level.

Sources

  1. HealthCare.gov, deductible definition and exceptions (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
  2. HealthCare.gov, coinsurance definition and worked example (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
  3. HealthCare.gov, allowed amount (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
  4. HealthCare.gov, out-of-pocket maximum and exclusions (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
  5. IRS Publication 969 (2025), HSA eligibility, employer contributions and distributions (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
Results are educational estimates, not financial, tax or legal advice. They depend on the inputs and assumptions shown; check important decisions with a qualified professional. Actual policy terms and confirmed HSA eligibility control; this limited annual cost illustration is not a policy recommendation, claims adjudication or tax calculation.
Ryan O'Connell, CFA
Built by Ryan O’Connell, CFA, FRM
Finance educator building free calculators that show every formula, so you can check each step.
Formulas checked against 5 sources · Updated November 2026
Search
Contact Ryan

Get in touch

Contact Me

Have a question or want to work together? Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you as soon as possible.

Contact Form Demo

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Results appear as you type. Use the arrow keys to move through them.