Your loan and actual quotes
U.S. dollars; principal and interest only. The same lump sum reduces principal immediately in every choice. This assumes a fully amortizing fixed-rate loan just after a regular payment, with each next payment one month away. Ask your servicer about eligibility, fees, minimums and timing.
Payment relief and total cost
The lowest modeled cost depends on your quote, holding period and savings assumption. The comparison includes the debt still owed at that horizon.
Lowest modeled present cost:
Recast availability:
- Original required monthly P&I
- Principal after the common lump sum
- Equal starting cash available to each choice
- Equal monthly budget for each choice
| Measure | Lump-sum prepayment | Recast | Refinance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Required P&I ($/month; final may be smaller) | |||
| Monthly payment reduction from original | |||
| Payoff (months from now) | |||
| Cash used now, including lump sum | |||
| Cash retained at start | |||
| Loan payments through horizon | |||
| Remaining debt at horizon | |||
| Saved cash at horizon | |||
| Saved cash minus debt at horizon | |||
| Nominal outflows plus remaining debt | |||
| Present cost including remaining debt | |||
| Interest through each loan’s own payoff |
Saved cash includes unused upfront cash and every monthly budget difference, reinvested at your assumption. A negative net position means remaining debt exceeds that saved cash; the home’s common value is omitted. Lifetime interest uses each loan’s own term and is not the equal-horizon ranking.
- Recast present savings versus prepayment
- Refinance present savings versus prepayment
- Recast advantage at the horizon
- Refinance advantage at the horizon
A positive advantage favors that choice over ordinary prepayment. Present savings and horizon advantage are the same benefit expressed at different dates; do not add them together. Choices within half a cent of the lowest present cost are shown together.
How the comparison works
For balance B and n months, monthly principal and interest is B × r ÷ [1 − (1 + r)−n], where r = entered annual interest rate (%) / 1200. For example, 6% gives r = 6 / 1200 = 0.005 per month. At 0% interest, payment is B ÷ n. All options apply the entered principal lump sum L now. A recast recalculates the payment on B − L at the same rate and remaining term. Ordinary prepayment keeps the original payment and stops once the remaining principal and interest are paid. Refinancing replaces B − L with a new fixed-rate loan, plus only the entered financed fees.
Present cost = cash used now + discounted monthly loan payments + discounted debt at the comparison horizon. The monthly discount factor comes from the effective annual opportunity rate. An alternative equal-budget savings account invests all unused upfront and monthly cash. Its terminal balance less remaining debt gives exactly the same ranking. We use the cost equation once; saved cash is shown as an explanatory alternative, not subtracted a second time.
A checkable zero-rate example
Start with $120,000 principal, 120 months remaining and 0% interest. Apply $24,000 now. Ordinary prepayment keeps $1,000 monthly P&I and pays off after 96 months. An eligible recast at zero fee keeps 120 months and lowers P&I to $800. A 0% refinance over 120 months with $1,200 cash fees also has $800 P&I.
At a 60-month horizon and 0% opportunity cost, give every option $25,200 upfront and $1,000 each month. Prepayment has $36,000 debt and $1,200 saved cash. Recast has $48,000 debt and $13,200 saved cash. Both have a net position of −$34,800 and a $120,000 present/nominal cost. Refinancing has $48,000 debt, $12,000 saved cash and a $121,200 cost: its $200 lower payment does not offset its extra fee. A $300 recast fee instead makes recasting cost $120,300.
What to confirm with your lender
Check eligibility, the minimum eligible principal payment, the actual fee, required documents and the date a new payment would begin. Those rules vary by servicer and loan. Continue making required payments until the lender changes them. This immediate monthly model excludes processing delays, daily payoff interest, escrow/insurance changes, prepayment penalties and eligibility/underwriting decisions. Rates and fees are your quotes; no market quote or guaranteed investment return is supplied.
Sources: Chase recast explanation and eligibility; PennyMac recast definition; CFPB Loan Estimate categories. Lender examples support the general mechanics; your actual lender terms control.
