Use your plan's actual quotes. Defaults are fictional arithmetic examples, not market offers. Enter the monthly amount for the exact benefit option quoted; a joint quote already includes its survivor-option reduction. Inputs stay in this browser and are neither sent nor saved.
Quotes and assumptions
Pre-tax comparison
Enter your quotes and compare the same scheduled income.
—
- Account residual at horizon
- —
- Unfunded scheduled income
- —
| Pension payment PV | — |
|---|---|
| Lump-sum PV | — |
| Promised pension receipts | — |
| Account payments actually funded | — |
| First unfunded payment date | — |
| Funded amount on first shortfall date | — |
| Account first reaches zero on/after receipt | — |
| Dated annualized pension IRR (ACT/365) | — |
—
—
Payment, survivor and account schedule
| Date | Recipient | Pension | Lump received | Account growth | Account payment | Shortfall | Balance |
|---|
How the comparison works
Choose between the actual lump sum and the pension quote for the exact benefit option. This tool supplies no market quote, eligibility ruling or insurance guarantee. Both alternatives start with the same pension entitlement: accepting the pension gives up the lump sum on its quoted receipt date. The account gets only that lump sum, with no added contributions or borrowing. Pension income is consumed, and the account attempts to pay the identical amounts on the identical dates. Neither income nor investment opportunity cost is counted twice.
Dates, COLA and survival
Payments occur monthly from the entered first receipt date, preserving its original day with month-end clamping (January 31, February 28, March 31). Payments through the horizon are included. A fixed annual COLA first increases payment 13, then each twelfth payment after that. The survivor receives the stated percentage of the then-current joint amount, with the same ongoing COLA clock. The owner is paid only before the assumed death date. Survivor payments begin on the first scheduled date on or after owner death, only while the survivor is alive. The owner's amount does not increase if the survivor dies first. Death on or before first payment needs a separately quoted pre-retirement survivor benefit and is blocked. Death dates are scenarios, not probabilities or life-expectancy estimates.
PV and dated IRR
PV = sum of each cash flow ÷ (1 + effective annual discount rate)actual days from valuation / 365. The lump and pension use their own receipt dates. Nominal quoted amounts and COLAs require a nominal discount rate. Unrounded numerical estimates are displayed to cents; exact plan rounding may differ, and cents are not meaningful at exceptionally large projected values. The PV difference values only payments through the horizon. There is no inferred value for later pension benefits or a pension death benefit.
Dated annualized IRR solves sum of cash flow ÷ (1 + IRR)actual days from the lump receipt / 365 = 0, treating the forgone lump as negative and included pension receipts as positive. It is conditional on your death and horizon assumptions, and excludes any self-funded residual. It is not monthly IRR times 12, an offered investment yield, or annual pension divided by lump sum. That payout ratio includes principal and is not an investment return. Same-day cash flows are netted first. No sign change, all-zero flows, nonconventional timing (potential multiple or reversed roots), or a root outside the declared solver interval is reported as unavailable rather than selecting an arbitrary rate. The numerical search uses log(1 + IRR) from -20 to 20.
Self-funded replication and residual wealth
Between events the account grows by (1 + entered return)actual days / 365. Growth is after fees and before tax. On a receipt/payment date, growth comes first, then the lump deposit, then the payment. Withdrawals cannot exceed the available balance. A final partial payment and every later missing dollar remain visible as shortfall; no negative balance or hidden outside funding is assumed. If pension payments precede lump receipt, those payments are unfunded and not silently bridged. Later receipt cannot erase missed income. After both deaths, remaining assets continue growing until the horizon. A zero balance can occur on an exactly funded final payment without an income shortfall. No depletion within this horizon does not mean the account lasts forever. Returns are constant scenarios; market and sequence risk are not modeled.
Independent worked example
For a fictional $1,000 lump received January 1, 2027, a $100 monthly pension starting February 1, a June 30, 2027 horizon, no COLA and both rates 0%, five payments total $500. Pension PV is $500, lump PV is $1,000 and the PV difference is -$500. The account pays the same $500 and retains $500. With a $250 lump instead, it pays $100 in February and March, only $50 in April, then runs out; total shortfall through June is $250. These are hand arithmetic, not pension offers. For a joint $100 quote, 50% survivor share, owner death April 1 and survivor death June 1, receipts are $100 in February/March and $50 in April/May, totaling $300.
Supported scope and official sources
This version supports a qualified direct rollover to a pre-tax eligible account and an explicit equal-future-tax-treatment assumption. It does not determine tax liability, early-distribution exceptions, rollover eligibility, required distributions, benefit guarantees, spousal consent or plan solvency. Cash distributions, unequal basis/Roth treatment and early-tax cases are blocked. Pop-up, certain-period guarantees, refunds, temporary bridges, variable COLAs and nonmonthly schedules require their actual cash flows and are unsupported. No after-tax superiority or personally optimal choice is claimed. Dates 2026–2100 are supported scenario dates, not verified annual tax-law tables; the receipt/start/horizon must be within 60 years of valuation.
Official guidance checked November 4, 2026: PBGC benefit options distinguishes straight-life, joint-survivor, pop-up and certain-period designs; PBGC annuity or lump sum explains longevity, flexibility and inheritance tradeoffs. IRS Topic 413 explains rollover and withholding distinctions; IRS Topic 410 explains taxable pension payments, basis and potential early-distribution tax. Your plan documents govern actual amounts, timing and beneficiary rights.
