Your result
Difference in living value at year 5
$536 Whole life ahead at year 5
Whole life has $536 more living value at year 5 under the guaranteed quote and entered tax assumptions.
Out of date: fix the highlighted field to update.
- Term plus investments
- $7,964
- Living assets at year 5
- Whole life
- $8,500
- Guaranteed, after assumed tax at year 5
- Investments remaining
- $7,964
- End of policy year 5
- Extra term funding
- $0
- Through policy year 5
- Premium savings spent
- $0
- Through policy year 5
- Surrender tax allowance
- $0
- Guaranteed quote at year 5
Premium savings leave $7,964 invested at year 5
Assumes 4% annual cash interest and a 25% tax allowance, with premium savings invested at each year end.
Nominal dollars, not adjusted for inflation. This account path does not project policy cash values.
Show the data table
The chart could not load. The table above has every value.
Every annual premium enters the funding comparison
| Policy year | Whole life premium | Term premium | Signed premium savings | Investments remaining | Extra term funding |
|---|
Saved premiums are invested, spent or withdrawn
| Policy year | Growth after assumed tax | Invested savings | Investments withdrawn | Savings spent | Investments remaining |
|---|
Living values use only supplied quote years
| Policy year and basis | Surrender proceeds | Confirmed basis | Tax allowance | Living value after assumed tax |
|---|
Death proceeds include the investment account once
| Policy year and basis | Term death proceeds | Whole life total death proceeds | Investments remaining | Term plus investments | Funding basis |
|---|
Show the math
- Annual investment return
- 4% × (1 − 25%) = 3% net annual cash interest.
- Yearly premium savings
- $2,000 − $500 = $1,500 invested at each year end.
- Investments at comparison year
- Deposits $7,500 + net growth $463.70 − withdrawals $0 = $7,964 at year 5.
- Selected whole life living value
- $8,500 − 25% × max(0, $8,500 − $10,000) = $8,500.
- Selected event difference
- $8,500 − $7,964 ≈ $536 more living value at year 5; calculations use unrounded values.
Understanding term vs whole life
What the result means
The headline compares resources at one policy year under your supplied quotes. Living value means cash you could access by surrendering whole life, after an assumed tax allowance, versus the term strategy's investment account. Death resources mean the alternative amount beneficiaries receive: quoted insurance proceeds plus any separate investments. These are different events. Neither is an overall judgment about the insurance contract.
How it is calculated
Both new policies start together with no existing policy value or investment account. The whole life premium sets each year's common household budget. If term costs less, the difference is invested or spent as you select. If term costs more, investments fund the difference first. Any remainder is extra term funding. Growth comes before the modeled year-end cash flows; actual monthly or beginning-year payment dates may produce different results.
Whole life living value uses the exact supplied surrender proceeds and confirmed investment in the contract, or basis. Only a positive surrender gain receives the entered tax allowance. Basis is not automatically equal to premiums paid. At death, the supplied total whole life proceeds are used once; cash value is not added again. Guaranteed and illustrated quotes stay separate, and missing years stay unavailable.
Worked example
Suppose whole life costs $2,000 and term costs $500 in each of five years. Investing the $1,500 annual difference at 4% cash interest, with a 25% annual interest-tax allowance, gives a 3% net return. The year-end account balances are $1,500, $3,045, $4,636, $6,275 and $7,964.
The hypothetical guaranteed year-five surrender proceeds are $8,500 and the confirmed basis is $10,000, so there is no modeled taxable gain. Whole life has $536 more living value at year five, using unrounded amounts. For the alternative death event, supplied $500,000 proceeds under either policy give term plus investments $507,964 and whole life $500,000. Those figures compare different possible events, not amounts received together.
What changes the result most
Actual renewal premiums can reverse the annual saving. A higher assumed investment return raises the term account, while spending savings removes that asset. Whole life's supplied surrender proceeds, confirmed basis and total death coverage can change the selected comparison. An illustration is not a promise, and a return assumption is not a forecast.
Limits and assumptions
This version accepts every annual premium through a selected horizon of 1–30 years and up to three exact quote years. It does not invent renewal prices, insurability, benefits or interpolation. Extra term funding ends the equal-resource headline comparison; later savings do not erase that history. Spent savings are shown as consumption, separately from assets. Investing at 0% still builds an account.
Choose either a return already net of all investment taxes and fees, including any liquidation or death effects, or annually taxable cash interest with a tax allowance paid from that account. Neither mode adds another investment tax at the end. Surrender taxes are an estimate under your entered allowance, not a tax return. All dollars are nominal and not adjusted for inflation.
New personal policies must share a start and consistent premium assumptions. Existing-policy replacement, initial cash value, loans, modified endowment contracts, transfers for value or reportable sales, business or split-dollar arrangements, outside cash distributions, accelerated benefits and taxable interest on death payments are excluded. Estate taxes and deferred capital-gain realization are not modeled. Keep actual quote documents private and confirm their definitions with the insurer or tax adviser.
Use the life insurance needs calculator to estimate coverage needs, the compound interest calculator to explore a separate savings plan, and the budget planner to check affordability.
Frequently asked questions
Does this calculator predict whole life cash value?
Why is surrender value separate from death proceeds?
What if term premiums become more expensive?
Is spending saved premiums the same as investing at zero return?
Which investment taxes are included?
Can I compare an existing policy, policy loans or a MEC?
Sources
- NAIC Life Insurance Buyer’s Guide, Utah Insurance Department (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
- IRS Publication 525 (2025), life insurance proceeds and surrender basis (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
- IRS Topic 403, annually taxable interest (opens in a new tab)Checked November 2026
Explore related calculators

