Current loans and private quote
Your illustration
Enter the documented schedules and quote, then calculate.
- Refinance monthly P&I
- —
- Refinance starting principal
- —
- Cash to close
- —
- Refinance remaining debt at horizon
- —
- Refinance payments through horizon
- —
- Refinance interest through horizon
- —
Supported fixed-schedule comparison
- Nominal cost advantage
- —
- First-month payment reduction
- —
- Current initial monthly P&I
- —
| Measure | Keep current | Private refinance |
|---|
Monthly payments, interest and remaining debt
| Month | Current payment | New payment | Current interest | New interest | Current debt | New debt | PV advantage |
|---|
Each current fixed loan
| Month | Loan | Payment | Interest | Remaining debt |
|---|
How the fixed-schedule comparison works
Each current loan has an explicit opening principal P, fixed annual note rate and contractual remaining n monthly installments. Monthly rate r = annual percentage rate ÷ 1,200; unrounded P&I = P × r ÷ [1 − (1+r)−n], or P ÷ n at 0%. Interest accrues on opening principal before the end-month payment. Each loan keeps its own schedule, including its final payoff adjustment. We do not infer a term from the entered payment, combine unlike rates, roll freed payments into extra principal or assume approval.
The new loan principal equals the sum of all entered active balances plus financed true fees. Cash to close equals total true fees minus financed fees. Cash fees are spent at month 0; financed fees enter debt and accrue quoted interest. Fees appear once. Actual quoted principal and monthly P&I must reconcile to this model; a withheld-proceeds quote, separate accrued interest, penalty, ongoing fee or irregular first period needs another analysis.
For equal resources, each strategy starts with cash equal to cash to close, and receives the larger of the two initial required monthly totals every month. Keeping retains fee cash; refinancing spends it. Both make only scheduled payments and retain all unused cash, including after a loan is paid off, at the same effective annual net opportunity rate. The headline discounts actual payments, closing cash and remaining debt to today: PV cost = cash fee + Σ paymentm ÷ (1+d)m/12 + debtH ÷ (1+d)H/12. Advantage = current cost − refinance cost. Accumulated retained cash minus debt gives the equivalent horizon wealth difference, not an additional benefit. At 0%, nominal and PV advantage agree, and advantage = current interest − refinance interest − total fees.
A zero-rate example with debt still owed
Current loan 1 is $600 at 0% with six $100 payments; loan 2 is unused. A new 0% loan over 12 months with a $60 cash fee has principal $600 and a $50 payment. After month 3, current payments total $300 and debt is $300; refinance payments total $150 and debt is $450. Keeping has retained the $60 fee cash, refinancing has retained $150 from the same $100 monthly allowance. Net cash minus debt is −$240 versus −$300. Nominal and PV refinance advantage are both −$60 at a 0% opportunity rate, despite a $50 payment reduction. If that $60 fee is financed instead, new principal is $660 and payment is $55; month-3 debt is $495, with $135 retained and no initial fee cash. The advantage is again −$60 at 0%.
Supported schedules and limits
Use U.S. federal/private fixed-rate loans with documented level, fully amortizing monthly schedules, no forgiveness dependence and no changing interest subsidy or discount. Both strategies first pay in month 1. No extra principal, taxes or student-loan-interest deduction, exact daily accrual/statement timing, lender cent rounding, payment pauses, eligibility, credit-score effects, forgiveness value or discharge tax is modeled. Current variable, graduated, deferred, IDR, forgiveness-dependent or unknown schedules block the whole numerical comparison while preserving all active balances in a supported fixed private quote. A variable/deferred refinance quote itself is rejected. Limits: $0.01–$1 million per active loan, rates 0–25%, terms/horizons 1–360 whole months, true fees up to $100,000 and opportunity rates 0–30%.
Federal Student Aid guidance
Qualitative guidance checked November 3, 2026: Federal Student Aid, “Repaying Your Loans,” section “Should I refinance my federal student loans into a private loan?” at StudentAid.gov → Manage Loans → Repayment. Review current federal options with your servicer before replacing federal debt. This calculator does not establish eligibility for any particular income-driven plan or forgiveness program, and encodes no program-specific benefit or repayment rule.
