Skip to content

Annuity Payout Comparison Calculator

Compare your actual income-annuity quote with an account funded by the same premium, including survivor income and guaranteed beneficiary payments.

Use an actual insurer quote for the exact option. Defaults are fictional arithmetic examples, not market offers or mortality forecasts. The quote must already include its survivor/guarantee option adjustments. Inputs stay in this browser and are neither sent nor saved.

Quote and assumptions

Nonqualified exclusion-ratio/basis recovery, income tax, early-distribution taxes, withholding and beneficiary taxation are unmodeled. Equal starting money does not mean equal after-tax treatment.
Supported: fixed or fixed annual COLA; no pop-up; full quoted amount including COLA for the first N guaranteed payments, then the selected survivor fraction. Beneficiaries continue that full schedule after all annuitants die, only until N payments. Use 0 for no guarantee. Other mechanics are unsupported.
Include all upfront purchase outlay. No later premiums or outside funding.
The self-funded alternative receives the same amount on this date. Valuation must be on/before this date, and first payout on/after it.
Monthly anniversaries retain the original day, clamped to month end. Already-in-progress contracts are unsupported.
Payment 13 first increases, then every 12 payments. Same clock for owner, survivor and beneficiary. Enter 0 for fixed dollars; CPI/variable/calendar-year increases are unsupported.
Scenario, not life expectancy. No owner payment on/after death. Set beyond the horizon to model survival through it. Death on/before first payout is unsupported.
Joint quote mechanics
Apply only after a triggering death and the guaranteed payment count. The joint quote is already adjusted; no second quote reduction is applied.
Owner-only: if the other annuitant dies first, owner's amount stays full. Either: surviving owner also receives the reduced share. No later pop-up.
No life-contingent payment on/after this death date. Both annuitants must survive beyond the first payout date for this model.
0 = none; 120 = first 120 monthly payments guaranteed. Full amount and COLA continue during this count despite deaths, to a living annuitant or beneficiary. This does not promise a premium refund or a lump-sum death benefit.
Common horizon and rates
Up to 60 years from valuation. Payments after this horizon are omitted, including any remaining guarantee. Surviving this horizon never establishes lifetime sustainability.
User assumption for valuing dated cash flows, not an offered yield.
Constant scenario after investment fees, before tax. Real returns vary; sequence risk is unmodeled.

Pre-tax comparison

Enter your quote to compare the same dated income.

How to compare an actual annuity quote

An income annuity exchanges a premium for contractual payments. Enter your insurer's actual premium and quote for the exact single/joint life, increase and period-certain options. This tool supplies no market or actuarial quote, mortality probabilities, eligibility determination or insurer-solvency assessment. Guarantees depend on the issuer's financial strength and claims-paying ability.

Exact schedule and supported guarantee

Monthly payment dates retain the first date's original day, clamped to month end: January 31, February 28/29, March 31. The first payment is number 1. A fixed annual compound increase first applies to payment 13, then every 12 payments. This clock continues through survivor and beneficiary payments. No intermediate rounding is imposed; insurer rounding or date adjustments may differ.

The supported period-certain design pays the full current quoted amount for the first N payments, regardless of deaths. A living owner receives it first, otherwise a living joint annuitant, otherwise the beneficiary. After that count, single-life income stops at owner death; joint income continues only while at least one annuitant is alive. The entered survivor fraction applies after the quoted trigger: owner death only, or either death. The owner-only design never increases the owner's quote when the joint annuitant dies first. Death exactly on a payment date excludes that person's life-contingent payment. This is one explicit contract convention; do not use it for guarantees that reduce income during the certain period or pay a different beneficiary amount.

Present value and dated return

Each payment PV = payment ÷ (1 + discount rate)actual days from valuation / 365. Premium PV uses its actual payment date. The primary difference is included annuity PV minus premium PV; there is no inferred value for later lifetime income, remaining guaranteed payments after the chosen horizon, or an unmodeled refund. All amounts and rates are nominal and pre-tax.

Dated IRR solves the dated net-present-value equation for one negative premium and the included positive annuity/beneficiary receipts, using ACT/365. It excludes account residual. Same-day flows are netted first. A conventional negative-to-positive stream is solved by bisection of log(1 + IRR) from -20 to 20; all-zero, no-sign-change, nonconventional and out-of-range streams return unavailable with a reason. This return is conditional on your selected deaths and horizon. Annual payout divided by premium includes returned principal and is not an investment return or insurer yield.

Equal starting money and finite-horizon account

The account gets exactly the premium on its payment date, with no extra contributions, borrowing or tax subsidy. Between events it compounds at the effective annual return using actual days / 365. At a shared date, growth comes first, then deposit, then withdrawal. It attempts every identical annuity payment, including survivor and beneficiary amounts; both alternatives consume that income. A withdrawal is capped at available funds. Any final partial payment and all subsequent missing dollars remain shortfalls. Balance never goes negative. Remaining money grows through the exact horizon, even after deaths or the last promised payment. Exact final depletion can occur without a shortfall.

A residual is account wealth, not an extra annuity benefit. No depletion within this horizon does not mean the account will last for life. Constant-return estimates do not model market losses or sequence risk. The finite comparison is not an actuarial expected value or a recommendation.

Independent arithmetic example

A fictional $1,000 premium paid January 1, 2027, $100 monthly quote starting February 1, five guaranteed payments, owner death April 1, and June 30 horizon produces $200 owner income and $300 beneficiary income. At 0% discount and account return, annuity PV is $500, premium PV $1,000, difference -$500, and the account retains $500 after matching all five payments. With only $250 starting capital, it funds $100, $100, $50, $0, $0; first shortfall and depletion occur April 1, and total missing income is $250. These are hand calculations, not offers.

Taxes and unsupported contracts

This version deliberately compares gross cash flows before tax. Nonqualified annuity exclusion-ratio/basis recovery, qualified/Roth taxation, tax deferral, investment-account tax drag, withholding, early-distribution additional tax and beneficiary taxes are unmodeled. It never assumes identical after-tax treatment or declares an after-tax winner. Get a separate tax analysis for your actual funding source and contract.

Only a future/new single-premium monthly life-income quote with the stated mechanics is supported. Valuation must be on/before premium payment, which must be on/before the first payout; the horizon may precede the first payout. Both relevant annuitants must survive past the first payout. Already-in-progress contracts, pre-income death benefits, multiple premiums, period-certain-only contracts, premium/cash/installment refunds, pop-ups, accelerations, commutation, liquidity elections, indexed/variable benefits, variable COLAs, bridges and other riders are unsupported. Quote amounts: premium $0.01–$100 million and monthly payout $0–$1 million in whole cents; fixed COLA 0–10%; survivor share 1–100%; guaranteed count 0–720 whole monthly payments; rates -20%–30%; dates 2026–2100, and premium/start/horizon within 60 years of valuation. Numerical estimates display cents, which are not meaningful at exceptionally large projected values.

Official guidance checked November 5, 2026: Investor.gov annuities explains contract variation and issuer risk; New York DFS annuity products distinguishes life, survivor, period-certain and refund designs; Western & Southern IncomeSource Select product overview illustrates contract-specific survivor triggers and beneficiary continuation; Lincoln immediate annuity fact sheet illustrates anniversary compound increases. IRS Publication 939 describes nonqualified/general-rule taxation; IRS Topic 410 explains basis and possible early-distribution taxes. These sources describe designs; your issued contract and actual quote govern. No source's product limits are inferred as universal eligibility rules.

Search
Contact Ryan

Get in touch

Contact Me

Have a question or want to work together? Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you as soon as possible.

Contact Form Demo

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Results appear as you type. Use the arrow keys to move through them.