Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA)

Table of Contents

    If your 401(k) holds stock in the company you work for, check the stock’s tax basis before you roll the account into an IRA. A qualifying net unrealized appreciation (NUA) distribution lets you take the shares into a taxable brokerage account. You generally pay ordinary income tax on what the plan paid for the shares, then pay long-term capital gains tax on the appreciation that built up inside the plan when you sell. A direct rollover to a traditional IRA generally defers the entire tax bill, but taxable withdrawals from the IRA are generally ordinary income. [1] [2] [3]

    Start with two separate questions: does your proposed distribution qualify, and would it leave you better off after tax and after accounting for the risk of holding company stock? This guide compares the two routes for fully pretax money under U.S. federal tax rules.

    What Is Net Unrealized Appreciation?

    NUA is the increase in value while the employer securities were in the plan. In the simplest case, subtract the plan’s cost basis from the shares’ fair market value on the day they leave the plan. The cost is the plan’s basis in the shares, not what the shares were worth when you left your job. Get the plan’s figures rather than estimating basis from a historical stock quote. [1] [2]

    Federal tax on employer stock distributed in kind from a fully pretax plan when NUA treatment applies
    Part of the stock value When it is taxed How it is taxed
    Plan cost basis Year of distribution Ordinary income; this amount becomes your stock basis in this example.
    Appreciation inside the plan (NUA) Year of taxable sale or exchange, to the extent realized Long-term capital gain, even if you sell soon after distribution.
    Appreciation after the shares leave the plan Year of taxable sale or exchange Generally short-term if held one year or less after distribution; long-term if held more than one year.

    Only the gain you actually realize can get NUA treatment. If the shares fall after distribution, the sale may realize only part of the original NUA. Also, the net investment income tax (NIIT) treats the two gains differently: qualifying NUA is excluded from net investment income, while post-distribution appreciation can be subject to NIIT if the tax applies to you. [2] [4] [7]

    When Does an Employer Stock Distribution Qualify?

    For the usual strategy involving pretax employer stock, the plan must hold eligible employer securities, and the shares you want treated as NUA must leave the plan in kind. That means receiving the actual shares in a taxable brokerage account. If the plan sells them first and sends cash, there are no distributed shares to receive the treatment. If you roll the stock or its proceeds into a traditional IRA, the special treatment does not carry over to later IRA withdrawals. Employer shares you bought on your own and stock options that are still unexercised are separate from this rule. [1] [2] [3]

    The lump-sum distribution must be paid after the participant reaches age 59½, because an employee separated from service, because the participant died, or after a self-employed participant becomes totally and permanently disabled under the statutory rule. The full balance must leave the relevant employer plans of the same kind within one tax year. The law groups pension plans with pension plans, profit-sharing plans with profit-sharing plans, and stock bonus plans with stock bonus plans. Ask the administrator which plans are grouped with yours. Several transactions can empty the relevant plans in one tax year; starting in December and finishing in January crosses tax years for a calendar-year taxpayer. If an earlier partial withdrawal was tied to the same qualifying event and occurred in a different tax year, distributing the rest this year may not qualify. Ask the plan administrator and a tax adviser to review the distribution dates and any later qualifying event. [1] [2]

    Can You Use NUA for Only Some Shares?

    Yes, if the plan can carry out the split and the distribution otherwise qualifies. You can take selected employer shares in kind and directly roll the eligible balance into a traditional IRA, including other employer shares or the proceeds from selling them inside the plan. The required plan balances still have to be distributed in the same tax year. This can limit the basis tax you pay up front and the amount of stock you take outside the plan. Ask whether the plan lets you select particular lots and how it determines their basis. A separate, narrow rule can apply to NUA attributable to certain after-tax employee contributions even without a lump sum; it does not exempt a partial withdrawal of ordinary pretax shares from the full-balance rule. A required minimum distribution, if one applies, cannot be rolled over. [1] [2] [3]

    When Can the 10% Additional Tax Apply?

    Qualifying for NUA does not automatically exempt the distribution from the federal 10% additional tax on early withdrawals. If you are under 59½ and no exception applies, it generally applies to the part included in income at distribution. In the fully pretax example below, that would be the $21,000 basis, or $2,100 of additional tax, rather than 10% of the $79,000 deferred NUA. One exception covers distributions from the employer’s plan after you separate from that employer during or after the calendar year you turn 55. It does not follow you into an IRA. [5]

    Worked Example: NUA vs. a Traditional IRA Rollover

    Suppose a 62-year-old has $100,000 of employer stock in a fully pretax 401(k). The plan paid $21,000, so $79,000 represents NUA on the distribution date. Assume the plan can complete a qualifying distribution; any other eligible assets roll directly into an IRA in both cases and are left out of this comparison.

    Both routes start with the $100,000 stock position and $5,040 of outside savings. Give the stock the same hypothetical 10% annual price growth in both routes, so its sale value after two years is $100,000 × 1.102 = $121,000. The NUA route pays an assumed 24% on basis up front and 15% on all realized long-term stock gains at sale. The IRA route assumes a 22% average incremental ordinary income tax rate across the full withdrawal at the end of year two. Outside savings, if retained, earn 4% per year after tax. These are assumptions, with no dividends, fees, state tax, NIIT or required distributions in the example.

    Hypothetical comparison at equal starting resources, rounded to the nearest dollar
    Cash flows NUA distribution Full direct rollover to a traditional IRA
    Federal tax at distribution $21,000 × 24% = $5,040, paid from outside savings $0; outside savings remain invested
    Federal tax at the end of year two $79,000 original NUA × 15% + $21,000 later gain × 15% = $15,000 $121,000 pretax withdrawal × 22% = $26,620
    Cash from sale or withdrawal, after year-two tax $121,000 − $15,000 = $106,000 $121,000 − $26,620 = $94,380
    Outside savings at the end of year two $0; spent at distribution $5,040 × 1.042 ≈ $5,451
    Total after-tax cash at the end of year two $106,000 $99,831

    In the NUA column, the $21,000 later gain is the $121,000 sale value minus the $100,000 distribution value. It is long-term here because the shares were held for two years outside the plan. The upfront tax has already consumed the outside savings; subtracting it again in year two would count it twice. In the rollover column, the withdrawal creates the taxable income. Selling the stock inside the IRA without taking a withdrawal generally would not trigger current income tax. [2] [3] [4]

    Change the assumed IRA withdrawal rate to 12% and the comparison flips: $121,000 × 12% = $14,520 of tax, leaving $106,480 from the IRA plus about $5,451 of outside savings, or $111,931. A real IRA could spread withdrawals over several years. Compare taxes on actual projected income and withdrawals rather than treating either example rate as your bracket. A higher stock basis, a longer period of IRA deferral, or an upfront bill that uses up needed cash can also change the decision.

    Test the Stock Sale Tax Separately

    Once you’ve independently checked eligibility, taxable stock basis and the applicable rate, you can model the sale in isolation. Select Deferred Capital Gains and use the example’s $100,000 initial portfolio value, 10% annual return, 0.21 cost basis/current value ($21,000 divided by $100,000), two-year horizon and 15% capital gains tax rate. The After-Tax Terminal result is $106,000: the proceeds net of the modeled sale tax at one assumed rate.

    Use this illustration only when sale proceeds exceed your adjusted stock basis and one assumed tax rate applies to the entire gain. The calculator cannot determine the tax benefit of a capital loss. It also does not determine NUA eligibility, compute the upfront basis tax, the 10% additional tax, NIIT or state taxes, distinguish the two types of stock gain, model IRA withdrawals or tell you whether to keep employer stock. [4]

    A Lower Tax Rate Does Not Reduce Stock Risk

    You do not have to hold the stock for a year to get long-term treatment on the original NUA. If a sale is possible under plan, broker and trading restrictions, selling soon after distribution can reduce exposure to your employer. Waiting can defer the tax or change the character of any new gain, but a stock decline can erase much more than you would have saved. In the example, a 30% drop from $100,000 leaves $70,000 in sale proceeds and $49,000 of gain above the $21,000 basis. Only that $49,000 is realized, and the earlier basis tax is not reversed. [2] [8]

    Count company shares held elsewhere, equity compensation and the portion of your income that depends on the same employer. A direct rollover can let you sell and diversify inside the IRA without current tax on that sale. Taking fewer shares out under NUA or selling promptly after an eligible distribution can also limit exposure. Leaving assets in the employer plan, if allowed, may be another option. Compare fees, withdrawal rules and account protections as well as tax, and use your tax-aware portfolio plan to decide how much exposure you can afford. [3] [8]

    What to Check Before Moving the Money

    1. Get the plan records. Request the basis, current market value and estimated NUA for the shares, plus a complete distribution history and the plan’s in-kind and lot-selection rules.
    2. Confirm the event, required balances and deadline. Review prior withdrawals, any required minimum distribution, and potential residual cash or shares that could prevent the relevant accounts from being fully distributed within one tax year.
    3. Price the decision using your tax return and time horizon. Compare cash needed now, potential sale and IRA withdrawal tax, and the consequences of a stock decline. Review after-tax employee contributions, designated Roth amounts and special circumstances separately.
    4. Confirm both destinations before authorizing anything. Arrange the taxable brokerage for NUA shares and the direct rollover of the eligible remainder, if using that route. Read the rollover IRA guide for the transfer mechanics. Retain the distribution statements, verify the NUA amount in Box 6 of Form 1099-R, and check the broker’s basis and sale reporting against the plan records.

    Confirm eligibility, timing and tax reporting with the plan administrator and a tax professional before selling shares inside the plan or signing the rollover instructions. [1] [3] [6]

    Frequently Asked Questions

    The deferred NUA itself does not. If the employee dies after receiving the shares and before selling, the original NUA is income in respect of a decedent. It generally remains taxable as long-term gain when the heir sells, to the extent realized. Appreciation from the plan distribution to the date of death is separate and may qualify for the normal inherited-basis adjustment. [9]

    No. Multiple transfers can meet the timing rule if all required balances are distributed in the same tax year and the other conditions are met. A partial stock distribution with money left in a required account at year-end is different. [1] [2]

    No. Once you have rolled the stock into the IRA, distributing the same shares from the IRA does not restore NUA treatment. The taxable portion of that withdrawal generally follows the ordinary income rules for a traditional IRA. [3]

    Sources

    1. 26 U.S.C. § 402, particularly subsections (c) and (e)(4), and 26 CFR § 1.402(a)-1(b), for distribution, rollover and basis rules.
    2. IRS Publication 575, Pension and Annuity Income, “Distributions of employer securities,” and IRS Topic 412, Lump-Sum Distributions.
    3. IRS Notice 2026-13 (PDF), non-Roth appendix, “If your payment includes employer stock that you don’t roll over,” and IRS Publication 590-B, Distributions from IRAs.
    4. IRS Topic 409, Capital Gains and Losses, holding periods and character.
    5. 26 U.S.C. § 72(t) and the IRS chart on exceptions to early distribution tax.
    6. IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498, Box 6 reporting.
    7. IRS Instructions for Form 8960, the net investment income treatment of NUA and later appreciation.
    8. FINRA, Concentrate on Concentration Risk, and SEC staff bulletin on account recommendations, rollover comparison factors.
    9. IRS Revenue Ruling 75-125 (PDF reprint); 26 U.S.C. § 1014 and § 691, inherited basis and income in respect of a decedent.

    This article covers general U.S. federal tax rules. It does not determine your eligibility or provide individual tax or investment advice.